The Tepner Appt Group | October 2026: Understanding the Property Purchase Process
Providing insight to those looking to learn more about what’s involved in purchasing your first property.
Krueger, Joel
started transcription
KJ
Krueger, Joel
0 minutes 5 seconds0:05
Krueger, Joel 0 minutes 5 seconds
Hello, I'm Joel Kruger here with the Tepner App Group, CIBC Woodgundy. Very excited to be joined by Kishore Nagarajan today, bringing you an exclusive webinar. The whole premise behind the webinar is we're going to be focused on lending.
Krueger, Joel 0 minutes 25 seconds
So here at CIBC Wood Gundy, we're not able to do any lending ourselves, which is why we bring in our valued partners. So again, very excited. Kishore, maybe I'll pass it over to you and you can tell us a little bit about yourself and your role, and then we'll start to dive into some property questions.
Nagarajan, Kishore
0 minutes 42 seconds0:42
Nagarajan, Kishore 0 minutes 42 seconds
Sure. Thanks, Joel. My name is Kishore, Kishore Nagarajan. I've been a mortgage advisor at CIBC for 17, 18 years now, since 2010. And I primarily focus on residential mortgages.
KJ
Krueger, Joel
0 minutes 56 seconds0:56
Krueger, Joel 0 minutes 56 seconds
Excellent, thank you very much. So for a lot of our families, they have children and grandchildren who are starting to venture off on their own now and build up their careers and starting to look at potentially purchasing properties. A lot of that space is more esoteric. They're not really sure
Krueger, Joel 1 minute 17 seconds
where to go, what to look at. So I thought I'd ask a couple questions to try and give some clarity to that specific space for those folks who are looking to potentially purchase a property in the near term so that they have a little bit more colour. So I'll kick things off with a simple question. Maybe if you can just explain
Nagarajan, Kishore
1 minute 23 seconds1:23
Nagarajan, Kishore 1 minute 23 seconds
Hey Cortana.
Nagarajan, Kishore 1 minute 36 seconds
Hey.
KJ
Krueger, Joel
1 minute 38 seconds1:38
Krueger, Joel 1 minute 38 seconds
what a mortgage is and how does the bank figure out how much they'll lend when someone is looking to potentially purchase a property?
Nagarajan, Kishore
1 minute 44 seconds1:44
Nagarajan, Kishore 1 minute 44 seconds
Okay.
Nagarajan, Kishore 1 minute 48 seconds
Mortgage, in its simplest form, is just a loan secured against a house, right? A car loan, a car, the security on the car loan is the car. Similarly, a mortgage, you mortgage your house, which means the security behind the loan is your house or your property, right?
Nagarajan, Kishore 18 minutes 7 seconds
Five 1212 dollars a month, and a $2,000,000 mortgage will cost you $10,400 and twenty-four dollars a month.
KJ
Krueger, Joel
18 minutes 17 seconds18:17
Krueger, Joel 18 minutes 17 seconds
Okay, excellent. So that gives us a bit of an idea in terms of what the cash flow looks like. Any other like advice or intel that like you'd share with clients who are potentially looking at like going down this road? Like something that I've mentioned to our clients in the past is if they're thinking about
Nagarajan, Kishore
18 minutes 23 seconds18:23
Nagarajan, Kishore 18 minutes 23 seconds
Right.
KJ
Krueger, Joel
18 minutes 37 seconds18:37
Krueger, Joel 18 minutes 37 seconds
buying a property in the next, even if it's one, two, three years out, the more proactive you are in setting up a call and starting to go through some of the numbers, the better situated you're going to be when you actually go to pull the trigger, because it's going to give you an idea of this world and what affordability looks like for your particular financial situation.
Nagarajan, Kishore
18 minutes 47 seconds18:47
Nagarajan, Kishore 18 minutes 47 seconds
Mhm.
KJ
Krueger, Joel
18 minutes 59 seconds18:59
Krueger, Joel 18 minutes 59 seconds
Like anything else that you'd recommend to someone who's starting to look and like figure things out?
Nagarajan, Kishore
19 minutes 6 seconds19:06
Nagarajan, Kishore 19 minutes 6 seconds
The number one advice I'd give to someone who's looking to buy, especially for the first time, is let your decisions be governed by cash flow rather than impulses, right? That is the number one pitfall, like I do a lot. So just like this exercise I previously mentioned, let's work backwards, find out what
Nagarajan, Kishore 19 minutes 25 seconds
So, payment that works for you and base a loan amount on that.
KJ
Krueger, Joel
19 minutes 30 seconds19:30
Krueger, Joel 19 minutes 30 seconds
Excellent. So, like in closing here, I guess I'll just add a little bit of colour from like our standpoint at CIBC with Gundy. So obviously, we don't do the lending. We bring in experts like Kishore to help facilitate on that front. But there are also a variety of vehicles that we can use on our end.
Krueger, Joel 19 minutes 50 seconds
to help compound and grow the down payment so that you're in a better financial situation when you actually do go to pull the trigger and purchase a property. So A relatively new account, First Home Savings Account, if you don't own any real estate, you're able to shelter up to $40,000. There's an $8,000 limit.
Krueger, Joel 20 minutes 11 seconds
per year, it can carry forward one year. And so the advantage to using that first home savings account is you get a tax write off when those dollars go in. So you're making $70,000 today, let's say you put $8,000 into that account. You're only taxed on the net amount, so that's $62,000.
Krueger, Joel 20 minutes 32 seconds
for the year. And when you go to file your taxes, you'll get likely get a nice refund, which is fantastic. And while it's inside of that first home savings account, everything grows tax free. So 15 year time limit on that first home savings account, something to be mindful of. Another great plan is the home buyers plan.
Krueger, Joel 20 minutes 53 seconds
through the RRSP. If you're purchasing a property, you can borrow up to $60,000. If there's two people purchasing, they can each borrow $60,000 from that RRSP plan. Sorry, through the RRSP, through the home buyers plan, which you can use, again, to write off your taxable income, helps you get a
Krueger, Joel 21 minutes 14 seconds
larger down payment. And then later on, starting in the second year, you pay that back over a 15-year time period. So variety of different accounts, if you're not aware, that can help to build that down payment and help you save a little bit on the tax front. So feel free to reach out to myself or
Krueger, Joel 21 minutes 33 seconds
Kishore, if you guys have any questions or concerns or if you'd like to have CIBC help on the mortgage front. Any closing remarks on your end, Kishore?
Nagarajan, Kishore
21 minutes 44 seconds21:44
Nagarajan, Kishore 21 minutes 44 seconds
Just a reminder that there are special offers for Wood Gundy clients when it comes to mortgages, very competitive mortgage rates and line of credit rates that are specific to Wood Gundy clients.
KJ
Krueger, Joel
21 minutes 57 seconds21:57
Krueger, Joel 21 minutes 57 seconds
Excellent. Well, thank you very much for your time. Very much appreciate you joining us today and sharing your insights and knowledge and experience. So thank you very much on that front and we'll close it off there.
Nagarajan, Kishore
22 minutes 7 seconds22:07
Nagarajan, Kishore 22 minutes 7 seconds
Of course.
Nagarajan, Kishore 22 minutes 10 seconds
Sounds good. Thanks, Joel.
KJ
Krueger, Joel
22 minutes 12 seconds22:12
Krueger, Joel 22 minutes 12 seconds
Cheers, bye.
Nagarajan, Kishore
22 minutes 13 seconds22:13
Nagarajan, Kishore 22 minutes 13 seconds
All right.
Krueger, Joel
stopped transcription
Disclaimer
CIBC Private Wealth consists of services provided by CIBC and certain of its subsidiaries, including CIBC Wood Gundy, a division of CIBC World Markets Inc. The CIBC logo and “CIBC Private Wealth” are trademarks of CIBC, used under license. “Wood Gundy” is a registered trademark of CIBC World Markets Inc.
This information, including any opinion, is based on various sources believed to be reliable, but its accuracy cannot be guaranteed and is subject to change. CIBC and CIBC World Markets Inc., their affiliates, directors, officers and employees may buy, sell, or hold a position in securities of a company mentioned herein, its affiliates or subsidiaries, and may also perform financial advisory services, investment banking or other services for, or have lending or other credit relationships with the same. CIBC World Markets Inc. and its representatives may receive sales commissions and/or a spread between bid and ask prices if you purchase, sell or hold the securities referred to above. © CIBC World Markets Inc. 2026.
If you are currently a CIBC Wood Gundy client, please contact your Investment Advisor.
Trade, Tariffs and Geopolitics: Lisa Raitt on What Comes Next
Insight from Lisa Raitt for our valued clients
Appt, Michael
started transcription
Raitt, Lisa
0 minutes 3 seconds0:03
Raitt, Lisa 0 minutes 3 seconds
Hi, Michael, how are you?
AM
Appt, Michael
0 minutes 5 seconds0:05
Appt, Michael 0 minutes 5 seconds
Good, nice to meet you.
Raitt, Lisa
0 minutes 7 seconds0:07
Raitt, Lisa 0 minutes 7 seconds
It's my great pleasure to be here. Happy to talk to your clients.
AM
Appt, Michael
0 minutes 9 seconds0:09
Appt, Michael 0 minutes 9 seconds
Like.
Appt, Michael 0 minutes 10 seconds
Thank you very much for doing this. You are a former conservative cabinet minister, current vice chair for CIBC Global Investment Banking, and you are on the committee of some sort for Paul Kearney's US CUSMA status arrangement. I'm not sure what the title is on that.
Raitt, Lisa
0 minutes 15 seconds0:15
Raitt, Lisa 0 minutes 15 seconds
Yeah.
Raitt, Lisa 0 minutes 20 seconds
Mhm.
Raitt, Lisa 0 minutes 31 seconds
Yeah, that's right. It's a long title. I don't blame you. It's the Canada-US Special Advisory Council. Oh, sorry, it's a special advisory. See, I don't even know. The Special Advisory Council on Canada-US Economic Relations. So there's about 20 of us on it from all walks of life. There's union there.
Raitt, Lisa 0 minutes 49 seconds
There's management, there's big businesses, there's small businesses, the Chamber of Commerce. And I'm there from perspective of being in banking, but as well as my former experience.
Raitt, Lisa 1 minute 2 seconds
The United States.
AM
Appt, Michael
1 minute 3 seconds1:03
Appt, Michael 1 minute 3 seconds
Fantastic. The negotiations, tariff negotiations with the United States is the hot topic du jour. Where do we stand on the tariff negotiations?
Raitt, Lisa
1 minute 10 seconds1:10
Raitt, Lisa 1 minute 10 seconds
Mm.
Raitt, Lisa 1 minute 14 seconds
Well, we're taping this on October 14th at 930 in the morning. And I can tell you as of today, the last thing that I saw was Donald Trump saying to a reporter when he was kind of walking from one place to another that he wasn't interested in doing a deal with Canada. Canada was going to have to wait. And, you know, the typical
Raitt, Lisa 1 minute 33 seconds
kind of verbiage from Mr. Trump. Canada is a very bad person, very bad country. Don't read a lot into that. I mean, that's that is talk for the election period they're in right now. The midterms are coming up in November. Mr. Trump is going to be saying lots of things about a lot of topics. He's talking about buying diesel from Russia. He's talking
AM
Appt, Michael
1 minute 33 seconds1:33
Appt, Michael 1 minute 33 seconds
Yeah.
Raitt, Lisa
1 minute 52 seconds1:52
Raitt, Lisa 1 minute 52 seconds
about having a ceasefire, an energy ceasefire between Ukraine and Russia. All of these things make not a lot of sense in context, but if you think about it in terms of they're fighting a really tough battle to hang on to both the House of Representatives and the Senate in the United States, expect a lot to come out. From the Canadian perspective, I can tell you, and I do know this,
Raitt, Lisa 2 minutes 13 seconds
There are lines of communication that are open between Canada and the United States. Relationships have been formed between negotiators, maybe not the top ones, maybe not the Mr. Lutniks and the Mr. Bescens, but certainly with Mr. Greer, who is the chief trade negotiator, and with Janet Charlotte, who is our chief trade negotiator,
Raitt, Lisa 2 minutes 33 seconds
There's communication back and forth. So when the time is right to have a deal done, I can see us returning to the table. But the uncertainty about when that is, I think it's the one thing that really captures a lot of our time and attention.
AM
Appt, Michael
2 minutes 48 seconds2:48
Appt, Michael 2 minutes 48 seconds
How are they progressing? Is it is there are we down to a couple of just a couple of issues or is it is there a lot unresolved?
Raitt, Lisa
2 minutes 51 seconds2:51
Raitt, Lisa 2 minutes 51 seconds
Lee.
Raitt, Lisa 2 minutes 55 seconds
Yeah, so if you hear from the United States, what they will tell you is that they felt they had a deal last October. They also felt that they had a deal this past August. And in both cases, the deals fell apart. In the case of the last one, Canada walked away.
Raitt, Lisa 3 minutes 14 seconds
There's no secret about it. Now, the reason why Canada walked away was manyfold. There's a couple of things that hit the table at the very last minute that no prime minister would be able to justify, quite frankly. And therefore, that's why that deal fell apart. Whether or not a couple extra days of negotiation would have gotten us over the line, I don't know. But I can tell you that in my view,
Raitt, Lisa 3 minutes 35 seconds
from what I've read, what I've heard, and from talking to the United States myself, it came down to the auto sector. It came down to a tariff applied to the auto sector that was going to render it eventually inoperable in Canada. And if you know Southwestern Ontario, it's a really important piece of our business, very integrated,
Raitt, Lisa 3 minutes 55 seconds
very damaging to our economy to have that slow bleeding of auto out of Canada into the United States. So that was a natural deal breaker, and that's why we are going to continue to negotiate, I suppose.
AM
Appt, Michael
4 minutes 8 seconds4:08
Appt, Michael 4 minutes 8 seconds
How about dairy?
Raitt, Lisa
4 minutes 9 seconds4:09
Raitt, Lisa 4 minutes 9 seconds
So dairy is interesting. You know, we have supply management in this country. And supply management works to keep safety for our product, number one. Number 2, it keeps communities alive, quite frankly, that would not be alive, but for dairy farming. It's an important infrastructure.
Raitt, Lisa 4 minutes 28 seconds
And all political parties, all political parties are in favour of supply management. It wasn't always like that. Now there are individuals in each party that say, why do we have it still? Come on, we need to have free market. But at the moment, the politics are, dairy is very important.
Raitt, Lisa 4 minutes 44 seconds
That being said, there's always room to negotiate within that supply management agreement new treaties. And the dairy farmers understand that. They just have to be appropriately compensated for any changes to supply management. So eradication of supply management was not on the table. They weren't seeking that. They were seeking some clarification, some tweaking, some
Raitt, Lisa 5 minutes 7 seconds
some kind of re-establishment of the relationship, I should say. The claim from the United States is that we treat them unfairly when it comes to the quota system. That may be correct, but I also don't believe it's Canada's problem. I think it's the way in which the United States has set up their own industry.
Raitt, Lisa 5 minutes 28 seconds
that causes them to actually not be able to take up all of the quota that's allotted to them. So some negotiating around that was definitely a conversation, but it wasn't something that was contentious or that was necessarily going to stop a deal from happening.
AM
Appt, Michael
5 minutes 45 seconds5:45
Appt, Michael 5 minutes 45 seconds
So it's the auto sector is the big roadblock.
Raitt, Lisa
5 minutes 48 seconds5:48
Raitt, Lisa 5 minutes 48 seconds
Auto sector for sure, steel for sure. And just to give you some context, the reason why we were really hunkered down, now I'm not in the room. When I say we, I mean the country of Canada. Don't assume that I'm in the room because I'm not. We were really hunkered down negotiating because these last set of tariffs, what are called the Section 33A tariffs,
AM
Appt, Michael
5 minutes 57 seconds5:57
Appt, Michael 5 minutes 57 seconds
Yeah.
Raitt, Lisa
6 minutes 7 seconds6:07
Raitt, Lisa 6 minutes 7 seconds
They attacked small and medium-sized businesses in the country. Over 25,000 of these small and medium-sized businesses woke up one day and realised 70% of my revenue was gone. And they don't know how to get it back. A 50% tariff on their products going to the United States
Raitt, Lisa 6 minutes 27 seconds
rendered it incompatible with sales. So it was all over. So we were trying to ensure that those tariffs didn't bite because you knew what the economic impact was going to be. But as well, the government knew and understood that when we had the big tariffs come on steel and aluminium and autos,
AM
Appt, Michael
6 minutes 28 seconds6:28
Appt, Michael 6 minutes 28 seconds
Yep.
Raitt, Lisa
6 minutes 47 seconds6:47
Raitt, Lisa 6 minutes 47 seconds
Those industries know how to deal with that. They're big. They've got lots of government relations people. They know how to access BDC or EDC. These small guys, they're lost. And we may lose their businesses as a result of these Section 338 tariffs. So there was a really good, I would say, we were very much inclined to have a deal done. And for the prime minister to say we had to walk away,
Raitt, Lisa 7 minutes 11 seconds
definitely had to be something that was just not gonna, was not gonna fly when you balance it all out. But we're now on a time, we're on a clock. And as a conservative, and I am a conservative, and I think it's important for me to profess that, because that gives you an idea of how I look at things. But as a conservative, I will tell you,
Raitt, Lisa 7 minutes 30 seconds
very worried that the longer this goes, the harder it's going to be for us to retain those companies that are being impacted right now by these Section 338 tariffs. I would say January 1 is a really important date. And that's the date that Donald Trump has said he's going to levy a 50% tariff on autos.
AM
Appt, Michael
7 minutes 47 seconds7:47
Appt, Michael 7 minutes 47 seconds
Yeah.
Raitt, Lisa
7 minutes 49 seconds7:49
Raitt, Lisa 7 minutes 49 seconds
I would assume we're going to be back at the table before that date to try to prevent that tariff from biting.
AM
Appt, Michael
7 minutes 54 seconds7:54
Appt, Michael 7 minutes 54 seconds
I mean, that would crush the auto business on both sides, that kind of a kind of a tariff like that. That's the end of the auto business in North America.
Raitt, Lisa
8 minutes 1 second8:01
Raitt, Lisa 8 minutes 1 second
It would be, you would think though, you would think so, but I have to tell you that one of the biggest surprises I've had in reading media from the United States and talking to people in the auto sector, the United States automakers don't seem to be as preoccupied with the Canada-US issue as they are at the US-China issue, to be honest. They're very, they're very,
Raitt, Lisa
8 minutes 1 second8:01
Raitt, Lisa 8 minutes 1 second
It would be, you would think though, you would think so, but I have to tell you that one of the biggest surprises I've had in reading media from the United States and talking to people in the auto sector, the United States automakers don't seem to be as preoccupied with the Canada-US issue as they are at the US-China issue, to be honest. They're very, they're very,
Raitt, Lisa 10 minutes 3 seconds
If the president, from what I'm reading, if the president loses control of the domestic files, which happens if he loses control of the House and the Senate, then he'll turn his mind to foreign policy, which the president does have a lot of power in. And that would be
Raitt, Lisa 10 minutes 22 seconds
Very interesting to see. And the foreign policy is separate from trade policy. It's not all in one. So he may focus on that. And everyone else after the midterms, the politics ain't over. It's going to be thinking about who is the Republican contender for the president, who's the Democratic contender. It's going to be like a switch. We're going to go from midterms to
AM
Appt, Michael
10 minutes 36 seconds10:36
Appt, Michael 10 minutes 36 seconds
Yeah.
Raitt, Lisa
10 minutes 43 seconds10:43
Raitt, Lisa 10 minutes 43 seconds
Who is it going to be in two years? And we may get lost in the shuffle. So when you say what is going to happen, don't count on the midterms being the saviour, but it may mix things up a little bit. And maybe Donald Trump will want to have a deal done under his terms as opposed to leaving it to somebody else. Or maybe he'll just make Canada suffer.
Raitt, Lisa 11 minutes 4 seconds
I don't know. Alberta referendum is going to be important. We'll have to watch to see the results of that, because he will make hay of that, I will tell you. And the BC election in Canada doesn't really matter when it comes to the big picture politics of it all. But that referendum
AM
Appt, Michael
11 minutes 12 seconds11:12
Appt, Michael 11 minutes 12 seconds
Yep.
Raitt, Lisa
11 minutes 23 seconds11:23
Raitt, Lisa 11 minutes 23 seconds
does. So watch for the referendum, watch for the midterms. And you may not know this, but at CIBC, we're going to have an after the midterms special kind of podcast webinar for clients. So we'll watch out for that announcement coming. We'll have some really cool guests.
AM
Appt, Michael
11 minutes 40 seconds11:40
Appt, Michael 11 minutes 40 seconds
Fantastic. We'll shift topics for a minute. Carney's proposed an associate membership arrangement with the EU. How do you see that unfolding? Where's the benefit?
Raitt, Lisa
11 minutes 46 seconds11:46
Raitt, Lisa 11 minutes 46 seconds
Yeah.
Raitt, Lisa 11 minutes 51 seconds
Yeah.
Raitt, Lisa 11 minutes 53 seconds
So we have a trade deal with the EU already. It's called SWETA, negotiated by my government, formalised and finalised by the Trudeau government. So it's a nonpartisan deal. We all agree in it. It hasn't been ratified by all the European nations. It hasn't been ratified by France. It hasn't
AM
Appt, Michael
11 minutes 56 seconds11:56
Appt, Michael 11 minutes 56 seconds
Yeah.
Raitt, Lisa
12 minutes 12 seconds12:12
Raitt, Lisa 12 minutes 12 seconds
I don't know if it's been ratified by Germany even. And as a result, it's kind of hanging out there. So perhaps the discussion that the Prime Minister is having regarding this EU associate membership is meant to try to get the rest of the EU to sign up on our deal. And I think that makes sense. I think getting closer to the EU makes sense if you want to do one-offs.
Raitt, Lisa 12 minutes 36 seconds
I have no problem with deepening our relationship with the European Union. I think it's smart. I think it's smart for trade. I think it's smart for defence. Where I hesitate, where a lot of people hesitate is I don't want their regulatory system, period. And I don't want, nope, and I don't want their immigration policies.
AM
Appt, Michael
12 minutes 52 seconds12:52
Appt, Michael 12 minutes 52 seconds
Neither did Britain.
Raitt, Lisa
12 minutes 56 seconds12:56
Raitt, Lisa 12 minutes 56 seconds
either. I think the reason why I say that is not because I'm anti-immigration. I just think Canada is a very different entity than European nations are when it comes to immigration. And we need to be able to forge our own path, just like we forged our own path separate from the United States.
Raitt, Lisa 13 minutes 16 seconds
We're multicultural. The United States is melting pot. There are two different ways to approach it. But I think I would approach the EU question with very cautious optimism. Yes on trade, yes on defence, yes on sharing intelligence. Definitely no.
Raitt, Lisa 13 minutes 35 seconds
on regulations and definitely no on immigration. So can you have all of that and be an associate member? I don't know. We'll see.
AM
Appt, Michael
13 minutes 44 seconds13:44
Appt, Michael 13 minutes 44 seconds
Interesting. Any other global developments, a couple of different global developments we should keep our eyes open for in the coming short term?
Raitt, Lisa
13 minutes 52 seconds13:52
Raitt, Lisa 13 minutes 52 seconds
Yeah, there's an election in Israel. And the question is going to be whether or not Netanyahu wins again. And I think it's one to watch and to note. I have no idea the politics of it or whether one party is going to win or the other. But I do think it's something to watch for because it'll have an impact
Raitt, Lisa 14 minutes 11 seconds
on that war, that conflict that's happening over in the Middle East, which by the way, going back to the United States, remember I mentioned that the Congress has the pocketbook, they write the cheques. One thing they can do is they can choke off the funding of this war with Iran.
AM
Appt, Michael
14 minutes 22 seconds14:22
Appt, Michael 14 minutes 22 seconds
Yeah.
Raitt, Lisa
14 minutes 30 seconds14:30
Raitt, Lisa 14 minutes 30 seconds
They can just stop all the funding. The tricky part about that is, is can't imagine an American legislator wanting to say that we're not going to pay our soldiers. So it's one thing to say we're going to stop the funding of the war. Quite a different thing to say that we're not going to fund our soldiers, because that's essentially what it is, leaving them hanging.
AM
Appt, Michael
14 minutes 42 seconds14:42
Appt, Michael 14 minutes 42 seconds
No.
Raitt, Lisa
14 minutes 50 seconds14:50
Raitt, Lisa 14 minutes 50 seconds
So Netanyahu, maybe what you will see, if there's no change in government in Israel, what I think the impact of the midterms in the United States will be is perhaps not as much support for Israel. I think they may go in that direction and in a roundabout way impact that kind of the conflict that's going on there, which is messy.
Raitt, Lisa 15 minutes 11 seconds
involves shipping and trade. And I don't see an easy out. One of our, one of the folks that does work for us at CIBC is Admiral Jim Stavridis. He does some commentating for us and you've seen him on our webinars. And he has said that, you know, there is no good ending to all of this.
AM
Appt, Michael
15 minutes 22 seconds15:22
Appt, Michael 15 minutes 22 seconds
Yep.
Appt, Michael 15 minutes 25 seconds
See them, yeah.
Raitt, Lisa
15 minutes 31 seconds15:31
Raitt, Lisa 15 minutes 31 seconds
for the United States or for or for Mr. Trump, because they may lose control of the Strait of Hermos. They may end up having to pay around some money. They may end up having a situation that's worse than when they went in before. And, you know, we used to talk a lot about how we had to find their nuclear stores. We had to find their
Raitt, Lisa 15 minutes 50 seconds
you know, the uranium that they were storing, the weapons-grade uranium. Now, we haven't heard about that in a while, have we? So it's kind of falling to the back. So it's one to watch. It's going to be impactful, but not from a point that we have to worry about it here, but from a point of how the United States may flex their new
AM
Appt, Michael
15 minutes 50 seconds15:50
Appt, Michael 15 minutes 50 seconds
Yeah.
Raitt, Lisa
16 minutes 9 seconds16:09
Raitt, Lisa 16 minutes 9 seconds
government that, well, not their new government, but you know, their new balance of power, I'll say, in the United States.
AM
Appt, Michael
16 minutes 16 seconds16:16
Appt, Michael 16 minutes 16 seconds
Well, fantastic. Thank you very much for taking the time to do this. Really appreciate it.
Raitt, Lisa
16 minutes 20 seconds16:20
Raitt, Lisa 16 minutes 20 seconds
That's my great pleasure. Thank you.
AM
Appt, Michael
16 minutes 21 seconds16:21
Appt, Michael 16 minutes 21 seconds
Thanks.
Appt, Michael
stopped transcription
Disclaimers
CIBC Private Wealth consists of services provided by CIBC and certain of its subsidiaries, including CIBC Wood Gundy, a division of CIBC World Markets Inc. The CIBC logo and “CIBC Private Wealth” are trademarks of CIBC, used under license. “Wood Gundy” is a registered trademark of CIBC World Markets Inc.This information, including any opinion, is based on various sources believed to be reliable, but its accuracy cannot be guaranteed and is subject to change.If you are currently a CIBC Wood Gundy client, please contact your Investment Advisor.
My conversation with the Canadian Economist David Rosenberg
Senior Wealth Advisor, Michael Appt in conversation with Canadian Economist, David Rosenberg.
David Rosenberg Michael Appt-20261001_100608-Meeting Recording
1 October 2026, 02:06pm
26m 47s
Appt, Michael started transcription
Appt, Michael 0:03
now the founder of Roseberg Research.
David, lots going on out there. What is your take on the markets at this time?
David Rosenberg 0:12
Well, there's lots of moving pieces. You know, we still have what I consider to be a very significant bubble in the AI space. Lots, lots of revenue growth priced in to that part of the market, notwithstanding the fact that it's been behaving so well.
And then we have this energy price situation on our hands, which has been inflationary. It's keeping central banks on guard. It's also a margin crimp in a lot of industries, and it's an effective tax increase for the household sector. So, you know, that's obviously, I think right now, one of the
biggest constraints on the economy and obviously the impact it's having on the bond market sending interest rates higher, you know, that's probably front and center. The biggest worry that I have right now is just how long this energy price situation is going to last.
Appt, Michael 1:10
Where do you see interest rates going?
David Rosenberg 1:13
Well, firstly in Canada, it's rather amazing that notwithstanding how soft the economy is here, we just came off a month where we had job loss, flat GDP, underlying inflation, believe it or not, despite all the anxiety, is only running around 2%, which is close to the Bank of Canada's target.
And the markets are going to price in five rate hikes out of the Bank of Canada over the next 12 months, which is even more than what's priced into the Fed. So that's one of the reasons why interest rates here have jumped. It's obviously influenced the mortgage market. I think it's way overdone.
So, you know, these interest rate jitters could last a few more weeks. You could argue a few more months, but I think if you're going to ask me in the next, say, you know, 6 to 12 months, I think interest rates are going to be lower than they are right now. I think interest rates will be lower. The last thing I recommend anybody doing is extrapolating this current environment.
Appt, Michael 2:06
Lower.
David Rosenberg 2:15
you know, into the next one to two years. I think that at some point it says, as Herb Stein, you know, Richard Nixon's chief economist way back in the day famously said, anything that can't last forever by definition won't. And so unless we think this conflict with Iran is never going to get resolved,
Appt, Michael 2:18
Mm.
David Rosenberg 2:36
If we think that oil prices will just continue to go up and up and up and then feed through into other prices and into wages, there's no reason why interest rates will have to go up. You know, the one thing that I'm telling my clients is look what happened with the tariffs, which I'm sure we're going to get into. I mean, Liberation Day was April 2025 and everybody said we're going to get big inflation, big inflation.
And where's the tariff inflation? We had it for a few months and then it's faded. I mean, when you go to the United States and you look at the year-over-year trend in what's called core goods CPI, which is the product sector, excluding food and energy, but this is where the tariffs hit. That year-over-year trend right now is the grand total of 0.7%.
This time last year is 1.5%. So, you know, somebody ate those tariffs. I mean, they came and they existed, but was it the exporter? Was it the importer of origin? Did it show up in compressed margins in the affected industries? Because the one thing you know about the consumer price index
is that as final retail inflation. And it never really showed up forcefully, and now it's decelerating. So I say, well, if we didn't get the big inflation from the tariff shock,
Are we going to get the big inflation from the energy shock, notwithstanding the fact that statistically, arithmetically, it shows up for a few months in the data? It has to be persistent. Okay, Mike, it takes me back to when oil prices were going up to $150 a barrel back in the summer of 2008. And the chief economist at CIBC at the time, Jeff Rubin,
who was a longtime friend of mine, put out a book on oil and was calling for $200. Yeah, well, inflation in the summer of 2008 got to 6%. You know, right now in Canada, the US, it's 3% plus, and we're going crazy over inflation. Oh my God, it's just over 3%.
Appt, Michael 4:25
Yeah, I remember that. Yep.
David Rosenberg 4:39
It was 6% in the summer of 2008, and once again, everybody extrapolated, but once the oil price stopped going up.
And we got to like $150 for a day.
In the summer of 2008, inflation was negative 2%, negative 2%. Went from plus 6 to minus 2. And I was saying back then, and I was at Merrill Lynch in New York on the front lines, I was saying don't extrapolate this oil price into the future because it's going to be self-defeating. It's going to create the conditions for either a recession
or a contraction in consumer demand that is going to basically, as they say, foist itself on its own petard, which is basically, it'll just be self-defeating. I've never seen a period outside of, say, the 1970s when oil prices were practically doubling every single day.
year because of the OPEC embargo.
Oil tends to be self-correcting. And I see this as near-term inflation, but I look at it as a tax increase for all of us. And that leaves less money left over to go buy other things. And that's disinflationary. So just use that as your template. Summer of 08, $150 oil,
It doubled in a short span. Once it stopped going up, inflation went from plus 6 to minus 2. Interest rates came down. If I, you know, when I tried to sell that story in the summer of 08, believe me, when I was at Mother Merrill, people wanted to carry me out in a gurney or take me out to the nearest psychiatric ward.
Appt, Michael 6:16
Yeah.
David Rosenberg 6:16
But no, I think that interest rates right now are just too high, not just in Canada, I think in the US too, where you can argue the economy is doing better. Interest rates have risen too high relative to the state of the economy. And that's going to bring down economic growth. I believe that oil prices will stabilise at some point.
Most likely will end up coming down, although we're not going to go back to the pre-war lows. But you don't need to do that to get inflation back down. So I'm actually of the view that inflation concerns are overdone.
and that interest rate fears are overdone. And as a result, I'm fairly constructive on the bond market, both in Canada and the United States from these elevated interest rate levels.
Appt, Michael 7:00
Interesting. You mentioned tariffs. How do you see that playing out with our friends to the south, the whole situation, right?
David Rosenberg 7:07
Up.
Well, you know, you're asking me to play the role of psychologist, you know, in terms of trying to get inside Donald Trump's brain, which is a pretty scary thought. Well, I think that from what we know, look, on this latest round of tariff increases and then Canada's retaliation, we're not talking with them right now.
Appt, Michael 7:16
Yeah.
David Rosenberg 7:28
Mark Carney has his popularity has not been higher at any point during his prime ministership. So he's getting kudos for this, although, you know, the economy is going to take some pain. I don't overplay that situation because a lot of the tariffs that were brought in in this last round were really targeted to like
Appt, Michael 7:33
Yep.
David Rosenberg 7:48
you know, $30 billion of Canadian goods. And, you know, we're a $3 trillion economy. So, you know, the impact on GDP growth is going to be measured in basis points. You know, in terms of the future, the question is going to be, is Trump going to live up to his threat that he's going to double?
Auto tariffs to 50% from twenty-five percent of January the first. Is that sabre rattling, or is it really gonna do it? Well, he...
Appt, Michael 8:13
Can he do that without just destroying everything? You know what I mean?
David Rosenberg 8:18
Well, it'll certainly have a, it won't, it'll have a big negative impact, certainly in Ontario and the manufacturing sector, broadly speaking, but it also have a big negative impact on North America in general because of how intense these supply chains are, especially in automotive. But you never know with Trump measuring his bark against his bite.
Appt, Michael 8:32
Yeah.
David Rosenberg 8:39
I think that, you know, it's one of these situations where, you know, as economists do, you know, what we call the bean count, you know, just adding up what is the basis point impact on GDP growth from these tariff increases. It's a situation where the indirect impact is greater on the economy than the direct impact is because it generates this
high and rising level of economic uncertainty. And what does that mean, for example, in the business sector, what we know when you model out uncertainty on companies, when they get uncertain, they pull back on capital spending. And then if they pull back on capital spending, they pull back on unemployment. So it's really this cloud of uncertainty.
going forward, that's going to have, I think, a big downward impact on Canadian economic growth. That's one of the reasons why I think that the Bank of Canada might be concerned about energy prices. But if the economy slows because of this uncertainty, companies cut back, which means that the unemployment rate goes up.
who in the labour market is going to have any bargaining power, right? So all we're going to end up with is negative real wages, which is going to lead to negative real consumer demand, which means that, yes, we're also watching gasoline prices and utilities, electricity. That's not the whole pricing system.
So you could say, yes, there's 10% of the CPI that's going to be punishingly high, but it's going to come at the expense of the other 90%. And that's the other point about, you know, this, the whole thing about Trump's mercanalyst approach towards his trading partners. And of course,
in Canada, is he's trying to build up a tariff wall, doing everything he can to incentivize companies to relocate their operations into the US. That's why his big mantra is, I want to make manufacturing great again. He doesn't finish off the sentence by saying, at the expense of my trading partners. And what makes Canada different than
Appt, Michael 10:32
Yep.
David Rosenberg 10:43
most other countries around the world is that we are the most dependent on the US economy. So we're sort of caught in a box. I think that the Canadian economy, I'm not going to say we're going to, I don't think the conditions are there necessarily to go into a recession, but I think if the Bank of Canada raised rates five times, there's no doubt that would happen. But
I don't think the Bank Canada is going to get pushed by the money market to raise interest rates. But I do think the economy has been sluggish. We had a brief period of time. I think when we had that...
episode of detente on these trade talks, things were starting to improve somewhat. Well, that's now in the rear view mirror. So I think the economy here is going to slow. I don't think inflation is going to be a problem. I don't necessarily see that the Canadian economy is going to contract or that this is going to be a horrible situation. But I am going to say that if there's going to be good news is that interest rates
are more likely to come down from their current levels. They're just too high. The economy can't withstand it. And I think that the Canadian dollar is going to be at risk, which of course creates winners and losers. If you're planning your trips to Florida, it's going to be more expensive. But that is going to be an antidote. The antidote to...
what Trump's doing on tariffs is going to come from the Canadian dollar depreciating, which it has been doing. And I guess that's an artificial way to offset the tariff impact to support the export sector. So, you know, lower rates, lower economic growth, lower Canadian dollar. I think that's what's in store for us.
Appt, Michael 12:11
Yep.
You mentioned artificial. Artificial intelligence is something that comes up all that time, right? We talk about that every day. You know, how is that going to affect the labour market? How is that going to affect spending? Where do you see this going?
David Rosenberg 12:36
Well, the way I look at AI.
is that it is going to be a huge boost to productivity. And I think that I think that the stock market loves that because productivity ends up leading to lower, you know, labour costs and it boosts profit margins. So the stock market loves that story. And I would say that.
That story is probably more than fully priced in, but it is a reality. But the thing about generative AI.
Is it going to lead to us producing more? Because I don't see that happening. I don't think we're going to produce more because of AI. I think we're just going to produce the same, but we're going to do it more quickly and more efficiently. So when you talk about the productivity, it's not just, it's not the output. It's basically...
the inputs to that output, i.e. labor. So the productivity is going to come from the denominator, which is labour input. So this is going to be labour cost savings in a major way. It's one of the reasons why I think that, yes, you could say that on a near-term basis, it's putting up pressure on memory prices.
chip prices, so on and so forth. But productivity is kryptonite for inflation. So if you believe in the productivity story, which I do, this is a fundamentally disinflation theme, much like it was with the internet in the late 1990s. So that ushered in a decade of very low inflation. Part of that is because of what it does to the labour market. It creates major disruptions. So
Nobody knows, you know, how many, how many like, you know, data coding engineers will be hired against all the middlemen in people in our industry, for example, financial services. It's hard to know what the plus and minuses are going to be. Will it be a net employment generator?
or a net employment destroyer. And there's all sorts of academic studies supporting both. That's not what's important. What's important is that it's going to create a massive upheaval in the labour market, especially in the services sector. Because normally in the past, when you had these major technological innovations that affected manufacturing, the blue collar workforce,
But the white collar workforce, Mike, which is me and you, this is going to have a much bigger impact. So look, if it's going to work, if it's going to lead to all these great profitability, productivity, and that's what equity investors are betting on, you've got to be betting on that that's going to come because generative AI is going to save on labour costs.
Appt, Michael 14:55
Yeah.
David Rosenberg 15:14
And it's going to result in a lot of labour upheaval at a time when...
bargaining power in North America. I mean, the degree of unionisation in Canada and the United States, this is not like the 1970s. The unionisation share of the labour market is at its lowest level in the post-war period. Nobody's got COLA clauses anymore. I don't mean COLA what you drink, but cost of living adjustments because of the 1970s.
Appt, Michael 15:37
Who?
David Rosenberg 15:40
Workers were insulated from price increases because their wages immediately caught up with inflation. That's not going to happen this time around. So I look at this as I see the positives and negatives on both sides, but I think that when you get upheaval and uncertainty in the labour market, not getting into the debate is to
Will it be net job loss or net job gain? It's just the, again, what I talked about before, the general level of uncertainty. And I said before that when the uncertainty with the tariffs hits the business sector, companies turn more cautious. They spend less on capital spending. They keep more of their retained earnings on their balance sheet.
And the household sector is the same. And consumer spending is 70% of GDP in the US. It's 60% of spending in Canada. The AI boom hasn't changed that arithmetic. So what happens when you become more uncertain, even if you have your job?
You become more uncertain about your own prospect. You spend less of your after-tax income. You pull in your horns and you build liquidity. But that comes at the expense of GDP growth once again. So that's how I look at how this is going to play out in the labour market. I think that even without getting into that debate of job loss,
job gains. The upheaval and the uncertainty is going to ensure that wage growth, which is already slowing down in the United States, that doesn't get a lot of play. Everybody's focused on oil prices and crack spreads and diesel. And of course, the Fed's reaction function to all that and the Bank of Canada's reaction function, they're all just focused on energy prices.
But if you're taking a look at wage trends, as it stands right now, and we aren't at the full, what I call upheaval impact from AI just yet, but wage growth is slowing down on both sides of the border, to which I say, when you consider that labour costs are the most important costs,
in the retail sector, by far, by a factor of 10, more important than energy. I know people realise that labour is the key. So there's no inflation, sustainability without the labour market.
playing along. And if anything, wage growth right now is decelerating and will decelerate further. So that's where, you know, I come out of this whole AI debate on the labour market. It's going to lead to slower wage growth. Ergo, it is disinflationary. I just wish people would get off the inflation train just because of what's happening with energy prices right now.
I'll make an ironclad forecast. This time next year, we'll be talking about something else other than gasoline, diesel, WTI. Okay, we'll be talking about something else this time next year. And I don't think it's going to be about inflation.
Appt, Michael 18:24
Wow, interesting. Topic change, the other one that people are focused on at the moment is the upcoming midterms in the US. How do you see that playing out? How will that affect us?
David Rosenberg 18:37
Well, you know, it's not going to affect Canada, except through the bond market. And let me explain. We've had...
Several years now in the United States have just...
unrepentant fiscal stimulus. I mean, deficits, 5, 6% of GDP per year. You can't differentiate the Republicans from the Democrats anymore when it comes to fiscal policy. They're both irresponsible. And we're left with this mountain of debt, this mountain of deficits.
And the deficits, along with the, I mean, people talk about, well, look what the AI boom's done with the economy. And look at the equity wealth effect in terms of the impact that's had on spending on luxury goods and services amongst the high rollers who are benefiting a lot from their wealth gains from
the boom we've had in the stock market. The third prong to the US economy has been fiscal stimulus. I mean, the one big beautiful bill was incredible. Huge income tax refunds, no tax on tips, no tax social security, the bonus depreciation allowances. This was a big deal. People talk about, look how great the US economy is doing. Well, a lot of that
That came from, we talked about artificial before. Well, a lot of that came from the government borrowing money to stimulate the economy through this gargantuan tax policy at a time when the unemployment rates at 4%. You'd think that you'd be carrying out this fiscal stimulus in a recession.
Well, what happens when we do get a recession? What are those deficits going to look like then?
So I'm building up to this because November 3rd are the midterms. And I'm looking at the polling data and it looks as though the House is going Democrat.
90% certainty. And now it's 60% odds in the prediction polls that they're going to take the Senate as well. So we're going to see a clean sweep in all likelihood in terms of the legislative branches amongst the Democrats. But for sure, we'll take one of the two houses.
One of the two chambers, and that's all that really matters.
So why does this matter? It's because of the way the elections work in the United States. It's not a four-year election cycle. It's A two-year election cycle. And the midterms matter, especially when you come off a national election, like we did in 2024, when one party wins all. And so Trump took the White House, Republicans took the House and the Senate.
And now that's coming to an end. Not much like what happened with Biden after his first two years, Democratic sweep, then split government. Same thing happened to Obama. Same thing happened to George W. Bush. Same thing happened to Clinton in 1994.
And this has a very important market impact. And the biggest market impact is on interest rates. So let me explain that what happens when you have one party rule like the US has had in the past two years, you get tremendous fiscal stimulus. They could do whatever they want and they want to promote growth like it's nobody's business. And that's what the Trump administration has done alongside
to help with Congress. The Democrats could do nothing.
Um...
But what's important is that November 3rd, that comes to an end and we get fiscal gridlock. So these years of tremendous fiscal stimulus is going to be in the rear view mirror. And that's going to have a depressing impact on domestic demand growth or GDP growth. So I went back historically, actually, I wrote a report on this and I found that
When you go in the United States from a period of two years after a national election where there's one party rule, and then on the midterms you swing either the House or Senator or both to the other party, what ends up happening? Well, because you end up getting what economists call fiscal drag.
As opposed to fiscal stimulus, GDP growth slows 80% of the time, inflation goes down 80% of the time, and bond yields.
And now they're the highest level in 1/4 century in the United States, just in the past few months. Bond yields go down 80% of the time over the next two years. So that's the magic of 80. 80% of the time, the economy slows. Not saying it goes in a recession, but markets move on the trend.
GDP trend slows, inflation trend slows, bond yields come down. So if past is present, then I think the bond market is going to be a good place to be. There's other reasons, by the way, I think it's tremendously oversold. But the conditions will be put in place.
by the fact that we're not going to have any more fiscal stimulus post November 3rd, that the economy is going to cool off. The implications could be very positive for the equity market. I'm not going to talk about AI. AI is just in a world of its own. Okay. And there's the problem I have with the AI trade is it's
Appt, Michael 23:54
Sure.
David Rosenberg 23:57
not about interest rates, about oil prices. It's about the speculative fervour that this part of the stock market, this part of the economy is going to deliver 50% revenue growth in each year for the next five years. That's to make the, given the huge scale of the CapEx commitment,
That is what will generate any reasonable return. That's what has to happen. They got to generate 50% compound annualised revenue growth for the next five years off a very high base. So when I say, I'm not going to say that's impossible, okay, what I'm saying is that it's improbable.
There's just too much priced into that space. And everybody loves it. It's a nice, sexy story. It's not unlike the internet back in the late 90s, the internet on steroids. However, if I'm right on the fact that there's too much Bank Canada tightening priced in, too much Fed tightening priced in,
Appt, Michael 24:45
Yep.
David Rosenberg 24:56
The reason why bond deals in Canada have gone up mostly is because it's the spillover from what's happened in the Treasury market. And if I'm right on the midterms and we get industry relief, because people realise that the fiscal situation, it's not going to get resolved, but at least it's not going to get worse. But you know that 80% of the time, and look, Mike, I will take those odds any day, 80% of the time,
Bond heels go down after the midterms in which the ruling party loses the legislative chamber.
Then you want to be in the rate sensitive parts of the stock market. Like forget about the index. You're not buying the TSX or the SMB of 100. You'd want to be buying the interest sensitives. You know, that could be, in my opinion, it could be the banks, could be real estate, could be the pipelines, could be telecom. You know, they say that Canada is really a commodity index, but actually there's lots of rate sensitivity in there.
So, pipelines, utilities, REITs.
the banks, telecom, the dividend payers that are rate sensitive, I think that they will come out of this actually outperforming the rest of the index so long as that election result comes to the fore. That's my expectation. There's going to be places, don't buy the index, be selective.
Appt, Michael 26:10
This.
David Rosenberg 26:14
But I think the rate sensitive sectors that have been hurt by this backup in yields in the past couple of months, I think that we'll get a nice positive mean reversion trade after early November.
Appt, Michael 26:28
Fantastic. I could talk to you all day. I know you have a tight schedule, but I want to thank you very much for taking the time to do this. It's very insightful. Thanks again, Dave. You got it. You got it. Bye.
David Rosenberg 26:36
My pleasure, Mike. Yeah, well, thanks for having me on. Take care.
Appt, Michael stopped transcription
Disclaimers:
CIBC Private Wealth consists of services provided by CIBC and certain of its subsidiaries, including CIBC Wood Gundy, a division of CIBC World Markets Inc. The CIBC logo and “CIBC Private Wealth” are trademarks of CIBC, used under license. “Wood Gundy” is a registered trademark of CIBC World Markets Inc. This information, including any opinion, is based on various sources believed to be reliable, but its accuracy cannot be guaranteed and is subject to change. If you are currently a CIBC Wood Gundy client, please contact your Investment Advisor.
Trade Policy, Tariffs, and Global Supply Chains - The Tepner Appt Group
Jack Manley, Executive Director and Global Market Strategist at J.P. Morgan Asset Management provides insight on current economic, market environment
Trade Policy, Tariffs, and Global Supply Chans - The Tepner Appt Group
Jack ManleyMike Appt CIBC client call-20260925_134144-Meeting Recording
September 25, 2026, 5:41PM
36m 16s
Appt, Michael started transcription
Appt, Michael 0:12
Hi, hi, Jack.
Nice to meet you.
+19*******34 0:15
Hey, it's great to meet you too, Mike. Thanks for having me.
Appt, Michael 0:16
It's.
Fantastic. So Jack, who are you and what do you do?
+19*******34 0:22
So my name is Jack Manley, and I'm what's referred to in sort of corporate jargon as a global market strategist at J.P. Morgan Asset Management. Basically, what that means is I'm responsible alongside A handful of colleagues here in New York City, where Home Office is,
for creating and then delivering a timely macroeconomic and market insights to JPMorgan's largest, most important clients across the United States and Canada. So spending a lot of time on the road, a lot of time with conversations, a lot of time with analysis and
and things like this, Mike.
Appt, Michael 1:02
Fantastic. Well, look, there's lots going on in the world right now, so let's kind of jump right into it. What is your current take on the market right now? Do we have room to run?
+19*******34 1:07
Yeah.
Yeah, you know, I think to have a conversation about the equity market, we have to have a conversation about AI. And to have a conversation about AI, we need to have a conversation about the US equity market. And I think if we turn to the next page here, which will be titled AI Related Industries,
we can get into a little bit more detail on exactly how I think about this stuff. Right off the bat, I think it's important to kind of put my cards on the table and say, despite some underperformance relative to the rest of the world this year and certainly in 2025,
Appt, Michael 1:35
Fantastic!
+19*******34 1:49
I am still very much a big believer in US equity exceptionalism. And I'm a big believer in US equity exceptionalism because technology and tech adjacent things that of course includes artificial intelligence, but is not limited to artificial intelligence, has become a long-term secular trend in the sense that
It's everywhere. Its integration is only deepening. You are only seeing more tech reliance, not less. No one will tell you that 10 years from now, we'll be using less technology than we are at the moment. And the United States has really put itself into an exceptional position for dominance in that space. So right off the bat, again, I have to say, in general,
As A long-term investor, I am a big believer in US equity exceptionalism, which means I am a big believer in the US equity market. That said, and this is a big kind of like that said, big, big, big caveat. This is not an equity market that is perfect by any stretch of the imagination.
We have deep, deep concentration risk in the US equity market. And that concentration risk stems from a couple of things. It stems from the fact that the 10 largest companies in the S&P 500 account for roughly 40% of S&P 500 market capitalization. So just by buying a
small handful of names, you're almost getting half of the index. These things have enormous gravitational pull. What happens to the biggest names kind of ripples through the smallest names as you think about index-based investing. And then of course, thematically, we have a tonne of concentration. We can see on this page that AI-related industries, so things like
the hyperscalers, which will be NVIDIA plus a handful of those companies like Microsoft and Amazon and Alphabet, plus the broader semiconductor complex, hardware companies, software companies, power companies. These names account for over 50% of S&P 500 market capitalization.
This is a market that has done extraordinarily well over the past, let's call it four years, right? 20 plus percent returns in 2023 and 2024, 16% returns in US dollar terms last year were up about 13% year to date in 2026. But it is a market that
Appt, Michael 4:01
I.
+19*******34 4:10
hinges entirely on the success or failure of this one big, largely unproven piece of technology, which is artificial intelligence. Because I think we can all kind of agree that AI is cool and very impressive, and in many cases feels like science fiction. And I would guess that most of us interact with artificial intelligence one way or another, but what's really difficult to conceptualise
is just how much money has gone into building this stuff out. We're talking about trillions and trillions and trillions of dollars, more money than many countries GDPs getting spent by a small handful of names on developing this technology. And this technology has not solved any multi-trillion dollar problems.
Appt, Michael 4:54
Ohh.
+19*******34 4:55
just yet. And so that leaves the market.
Appt, Michael 4:56
So, are they overvalued? Are they overvalued?
+19*******34 4:58
Sorry, say the mic. So that's, yeah, I mean, that is the, you know, gazillion dollar question right now. The cheater's answer is it depends entirely on what your time horizon is. You know, I very much believe that somebody is going to figure out how to effectively monetize artificial intelligence, how to make the economies of
Appt, Michael 5:00
Are they overvalued?
+19*******34 5:20
scale actually work to justify this extraordinary amount of CapEx. There have been, as far as I know, very few historical examples of bubbles, if they are bubbles, bursting and then not reflating. They just reflate it at a slower pace. You kind of have prices grow into
or earnings rather grow into multiples as opposed to multiples just ballooning with nothing sort of underpinning them. I think if you are looking out over the next 5 to 10 years, you don't really have much to worry about with the AI complex or the biggest players in the space. If you're looking out over the next 6 to 12 months, you are looking at a market
that is not necessarily in trouble, but a market that is certainly susceptible to shocks. Whether those are like geopolitical, headline driven, whether it's macro data, whether it's adjustments in rate policy, like what we've seen happen over the past couple of weeks, this is a market that's going to be a lot choppier, a lot bumpier because valuations are somewhat stretched.
because AI, while awfully promising, is still a largely unproven technology, at least from an economic perspective.
Appt, Michael 6:29
Interesting. Tariffs. I mean, that's the topic that you are here in Canada, right? That's all we talk about is tariffs and what's going to happen to Canada, et cetera, et cetera. What's your view of seeing in New York on how this is going to play out?
+19*******34 6:32
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah, so I think to have that conversation, let's turn the page now to a slide entitled Trade Dynamics. And what this looks at is the Canadian sort of export market to the United States, both in dollar terms and in terms of share of total US imports of
these goods. There is an asymmetric trade relationship between the United States and Canada. Canada is the US's largest trading partner by a wide margin and maintains a pretty significant trade surplus with the US economy. In other words, Canada
exports a lot more than it imports from the US. And exports in general are a pretty big portion of the Canadian economy. They account for roughly 25% of GDP. And of those exports, about 75% of them are ultimately destined for the US market. I mean, it makes
perfect sense, right? When you think about the geographic linkages between our countries, you think about historically speaking, the political linkages between our countries, this extraordinary connectivity between the US and Canada is quite profound.
On the other hand, though, the US does not have that same sort of dependency on Canadian imports. Now, there are very specific pockets of Canadian imports that are extremely valuable to the United States. By far and away, the biggest one is crude oil.
and energy products more broadly. You can also toss in timber there as something that the US kind of struggles to find elsewhere. You can toss in steel and aluminium to some extent. You can also toss, and I always think this is an interesting one, nuclear fission material, something that's
Appt, Michael 8:38
Hmm.
+19*******34 8:40
that's extremely difficult to mine in the United States. You know, a lot of people don't realise this, but I was in Saskatoon a couple of years ago, and you look around the airport, and every single sign around the airport is for uranium mining. Because when you think about the most important sources of uranium at the global scale, Canada is by far and away the biggest
Appt, Michael 8:58
Mm.
+19*******34 9:00
and most politically stable slash friendly of all the different uranium producers. Like I think the number one uranium producer globally is Kazakhstan, but I would imagine that the US would rather do business with Canada than with Kazakhstan when it comes to importing nuclear materials, which are critical for
nuclear power generation. I guess what that means, right?
Appt, Michael 9:21
I assume potash falls into that, right? Potash as well.
+19*******34 9:24
And potash would fall into that as well. Commodities are a big portion of this relationship. So you're in this interesting position, right, where on paper, economically, Canada needs the US a lot more than the US needs Canada. But in reality, Canada has a handful of tricks up its sleeve, I suppose, that helps to kind of
level the playing field in these trade negotiations. Now, as things stand right now, I mean, there hasn't been a whole lot of good news, right? I mean, this feels like a *** for tat escalation. Now, granted, it is starting at relatively small, low numbers. Yes, we're talking about 50% tariffs in some cases.
Appt, Michael 9:58
No.
+19*******34 10:08
But these are 50 percent tariffs that are targeting only about 20 billion US dollars worth of goods. This is a small, small portion of the total relationship between the US and Canada. But I think symbolically it is sending a very clear message that the US president is looking to extract more concessions from his
Canadian counterpart in Carney and is trying to play tough in this relationship. I think...
Appt, Michael 10:36
How do you, how do you see it playing out?
+19*******34 10:39
So I think, first of all, from a macro perspective, you know, the two big questions you got to ask are, A, what does this mean for Canadian GDP growth? You know, does this translate into a recession? And B, what does this mean for Canadian inflation? Do tariffs levied on American imports result in higher prices? And I would say,
The risks to the former are a whole lot greater than the risks to the latter. I'm more worried about growth than I am worried about inflation if this trade war continues. And some of that is because of A, right, the huge exposure that the Canadian economy has to the US consumer, which we chatted about, but also
B, just a few weeks ago, the Canadian government instituted a policy for tariff rebates. If you can prove to the government that the thing that you imported from the US that is now being tariffed was essentially impossible to find elsewhere, right? If you can prove that
This thing that I brought in, I can't get it in Canada and I can't get it in Europe. I can only get it from the US that you're actually entitled to a refund. So there's less inflationary pressure in many cases than you might expect. I think longer term from a policy perspective, you're going to see a couple of things.
The first is that if Kearney ever decides to reduce or eliminate the export of Canadian crude products to the United States, that would very much wake up everybody in Washington and I think force a much more difficult and timely negotiation.
US policy makers right now don't really care about the tariffs and bans that have been levied on American products. Like sure, they wish that certain Canadian provinces still sold American alcohol, but it is not the thing that's going to break the camel's back. If you eliminate crude oil exports to the northern United States,
that all of a sudden becomes a big problem. I don't think we're going to get to that point. I think as with many other trade negotiations that have occurred between the US and its various trading partners, this is ultimately going to settle into something that kind of feels like where we were before things kicked off back in July. I think President
Trump is perhaps a little bit perplexed by how tough Mark Carney has been in these negotiations. And I would actually think that he's probably gained a lot of respect for the guy as somebody that's willing to stand up for his country and his interests. And I think ultimately, you are going to see
negotiation, a push through and these tariff rates lowered. I think you're also going to see Canada continue to look for alternate trading partners. And that's something that has been discussed for a little while and gained a lot of momentum very recently with that sort of announcement that Canada may become an associate member
Appt, Michael 13:35
Yep.
+19*******34 13:41
of the European Union. Now, Canada, I think most people don't need to know this, Canada is not in Europe and so it cannot become a part of the European Union, but it can enter into sort of strategic longer term defence contracts and partnerships, you know, idea sharing, IP sharing,
more open borders for easier exchange of goods and information and people. I think Canada is very keen on leaning more into alternate trading partners. But again, Mike, to just kind of drive this point home, the amount of trade that Canada did with the European Union was a 10th
of what it did with the United States last year. You know, even if you double that, you are still looking at the U.S. being the biggest fish in a relatively small pond. So there are a lot of changes that I think might be coming from a policy perspective, but ultimately, I'm still assuming that piece is the ultimate
Appt, Michael 14:23
Yeah.
+19*******34 14:43
Group result.
Appt, Michael 14:44
Well, that's good to hear. For the record, we are right next to France. I don't know if you're aware as an American, but St. Pierre-Miquelon is a French territory right off the coast of Newfoundland. So tactically, we're right next to Europe.
+19*******34 14:49
Nation.
I.
Could be an interesting, an interesting caveat there. I actually just read about that the other day for the first time. I had no idea. But yeah, we'll see. Maybe there's some really creative political gerrymandering that happens. But I'm not holding my breath.
Appt, Michael 15:09
Yeah.
No, no. Moving on, the other topic that comes up a lot in my world is, are we all going to be replaced, right? AI and labor. How is this going to play out? How is it going to affect who's vulnerable, who's exposed to losing their jobs, et cetera, et cetera.
+19*******34 15:14
What?
Well, let's turn to the next page here, which has a more descriptive title. It's called The Labour Market Will Likely Undergo Significant Job Transformation. You know, that's one way to answer your question, Mike, is to say that, look, you know, the AI is going to change up anything or change up everything.
Appt, Michael 15:40
Yeah.
+19*******34 15:46
And I pulled this slide from a selection of slides that a colleague of mine who does a lot of work on artificial intelligence has pulled together. And what it looks at is the current exposure to artificial intelligence based off of cloud usage for all these different major industries in the United States.
and then compares that to the potential AI exposure based off of the kind of cognitive tasks that employees would do day in, day out, based off of some survey and policy work. Now, the first thing I would point out here is that you have to take these kinds of analyses
with huge chunks of salt. Because if you look at the sources of this material, the biggest one is the Anthropic Economic Index. And this individual whose last name is Ilan Du, alongside a handful of other people. These researchers are all in the employment
of Anthropic and other large language models. And that doesn't necessarily mean that they aren't speaking objectively. But when Anthropic is signing your paychecks or OpenAI is signing your paycheck, then you might be tempted or encouraged to envision a world where everybody's going to be made redundant by this technology that you are helping to develop. So
Appt, Michael 17:00
Hmm.
+19*******34 17:08
As with so many other things out there, like just remember who you're hearing this from, you know, what the biases are, what the incentives are for putting out these sorts of things. But when you put that, you know, when you kind of put that in the back of your mind and you keep that in mind, the rest of this chart,
I think generally speaking makes a good amount of sense, right? If you take it from the left-hand side to the right-hand side, you generally speaking get a good idea of how exposed these sectors are to artificial intelligence. And when you go all the way to the right-hand side of things, I mean, it kind of makes sense, right? Like difficult to implement AI in phishing. I mean, you know, at the end of the day, you can do all sorts of
Appt, Michael 17:46
Yeah.
+19*******34 17:52
you know, interesting analytical work using artificial intelligence to figure out, you know, like the best time to go fishing and the best places to go fishing and, you know, the best kinds of nets or whatever. But at the end of the day, the robot's not going fishing, or at least the computer programme is not going fishing, not anytime soon. And so you'll see that, you know, things like construction or transportation or, you know, maintenance and repair
Appt, Michael 17:58
Sure.
+19*******34 18:13
food preparation, very limited exposure to artificial intelligence, things that we do with our hands that require the physical presence of a human being, not a whole lot of risk of being eliminated by AI. You think about the other side of the page and with education and mathematics and business and the legal world.
These are areas where you're not doing a whole lot of physical things, not a lot of manual labor, areas where most of the value is created through brain power, through cognitive tasks, and those cognitive tasks can ultimately be, in many cases, replicated by AI. But I have to say,
You know, not everybody feels this way, Mike. I have to say, I am not one of these AI doomers. I'm just not. I would much rather think of AI as being additive, as being positively augmentative, than a negative for the labour market. First,
Appt, Michael 19:17
That's good to hear.
+19*******34 19:17
because, well, I mean, and you know, maybe again, kind of coming back to my earlier comment, like maybe it's because I want that to be the case because my whole job is like, you know, in theory on the line based off of this chart. You know, I work in financial services, like I don't want to lose my job. So maybe there's some wishful thinking here, but I really do believe
that, A, at the end of the day, human beings are social creatures and they like to talk to other people. You will never replace the value of direct interaction person to person. And I think that really becomes that much more important when you're doing things in person, right? So, you know, everybody imagined
post-COVID, that, oh, we're never going to go back to the office again. Everything's going to be done virtual for the rest of humanity. That wasn't really the case, right? People started to realize, like, oh, it was actually kind of nice going back into the office or nice going out for lunch or nice going out to the movies. We're social. We like being with other people. I would say the other thing, right, is that this idea
that AI is going to eliminate all employment, just doesn't really jive with the whole ethos of several 100 years of industrial history. Like if you are a business owner, would you want to fire half of your employees and maintain the same output?
or keep your employee count steady and double your output. Like you're always looking for growth. I would much rather skew towards this idea that AI results in a slowdown in hiring and kind of stretches out the hiring process and it results in layoffs. And I think you're seeing that in the data, you know, you do
see every once in a while some pretty high-profile layoffs, but those high-profile layoffs are typically concentrated at the big technology names. And while technology is a big part of the equity market, it's actually a relatively small portion of the economy, particularly from a labour perspective. And I think
You're starting to see people kind of change their approach as to how they use AI to make it more additive, make it more augmentative. Now, without a doubt, there will be people left behind. There are always people left behind in technological cycles. That's the way it works, right? When the internal combustion engine was invented, what happened to the horse and buggy driver? Like, that's just the way
that these processes evolve. But again, I am not a doomer on the AI side of things. And while I think that this chart we have up in front of us is a very interesting academic exercise and maybe suggests that some of us should go back to trade school as opposed to going to university and pursuing a very expensive liberal arts degree,
Appt, Michael 21:52
Yeah.
+19*******34 21:55
And I say this as a history major, right? Like nothing against that. Like I love my liberal arts, but I think this definitely gets an interesting conversation going, but I don't think we're heading towards some sort of jobpocalypse.
Appt, Michael 22:08
Very good. All right. The other topic du jour really is interest rates, inflation, right? Oil, et cetera.
+19*******34 22:14
Yeah.
Appt, Michael 22:18
Your take on all that.
+19*******34 22:19
Yeah, well, yeah, well, I mean, if we look at the next page here, it's titled the Fed and interest rates. Obviously the big, big headline right now is that the Federal Reserve hiked interest rates last week by 25 basis points for the first time in three years. It's been a long time since the Fed had hiked rates. And it is the sort of culmination of an
extraordinary swing in rate expectations from the start of the year. I mean, there was a period when we kicked off to 2026 and kind of moved through those early months when the war in Iran really started to get going, that the market was pricing in three cuts.
Appt, Michael 22:50
Yep.
+19*******34 23:01
You know, now it's pricing in three hikes. Like, I can't remember the last time you had such an enormous swing in rate expectations in such a relatively short period of time. And a lot of that has to do with, I would say, signalling and posturing. You know, this idea that
Kevin Warsh is the new chairman of the Federal Reserve. He's been in charge for only a few months. There were concerns about his credibility, concerns around Fed independence. You know, is he just going to toe the line? Is he just going to do what his party demands of him? And maybe he felt compelled to raise interest rates by 25 basis points to kind of
shake off all these doubts and say, no, I'm my own guy. I'm paying attention to the data. I don't just do what I'm told and kind of restore that image of credibility. I think that's part of it. I think the other part, though, is that the Federal Reserve, for better or for worse, is worried about inflation.
And, you know, so much of that inflation has thus far come from higher energy prices. We were looking at the cost of a barrel of WTI off the boil, but not too far from $100 US per barrel. And that's put enormous upward pressure on prices globally. I mean, in the US, we saw inflation jump from
2.3% to 4.2% in only a few months in Canada, we saw a jump of almost that magnitude, not quite as intense, but almost that magnitude. But when I think about where we're going from here, there are a couple of big, big questions, right? I mean, one of them is,
how much more is the Fed willing to do? And the Fed seems to be signalling that there will likely be one more hike before the year is up, and that would most likely be at the December meeting, I think.
but we'll kind of see. December feels like a pretty good bet for that. And a lot of that is going to have to do with how the inflation numbers roll through. And for what it's worth, Mike, like I'm not as worried about inflation as the Fed is for whatever reason, because so much of that inflation is
limited just to energy. And it's very difficult to see where energy prices can bleed into broader prices in a way that's big enough that it really moves the needle. Like you were still looking at core inflation that's pretty close to 2%. And that is ultimately what's going to be most impactful, I would say, for the overall health of
of an economy. I also think the Fed has to realise that, look, no matter what it does with interest rates, it's not going to reopen the Strait of Hormuz. Like the Strait is not opened or closed based off of monetary policy. Some things are just outside of the control of Kevin Warsh. So I would guess that the Fed does less than more and that that symbolism behind the hike
Appt, Michael 25:49
No.
+19*******34 25:59
was perhaps as important as the macro data that supported it. The other big question is, as we move through October, is the Bank of Canada going to follow suit? And I don't envy Macklem right now being in a very tricky position where the looney has been under
Appt, Michael 26:11
Yep.
+19*******34 26:20
quite a bit of pressure because of these growing rate differentials. The economy has been under quite a bit of pressure in large part because of all these trade shenanigans that we were talking about earlier. And the macro data in Canada do not really support the idea of an interest rate hike.
And the labour market is notably softer. We got a wage print number not too long ago that was the lowest it had been since 2017, which is pretty depressing. You know, the unemployment rate is structurally higher than what you see in the States. Inflationary pressure hasn't bled as much in Canada, and CPI numbers are lower than what they are.
in the US, I don't think there's a very compelling argument for Macklem to raise interest rates. But if he doesn't, then he's sacrificing the Canadian dollar. And how he sort of squares that circle, how he makes this all work out, I frankly don't know. As a data-dependent central banker, I
think he would lean more towards allowing the loonie to further depreciate if it means helping to support consumers that have gotten a reprieve finally from that higher rate environment that was such a problem in Canada for so long. That's what I would guess happens. And so I don't think
and the BOC are going to follow the Fed. But it is something that's very much worth paying attention to in the coming weeks, especially as we get more Canadian macro data informing us on the health of the economy.
Appt, Michael 27:51
And I thought if the war in Iran straight reopens, could that and energy prices certainly start to drop? Could that bleed its way through inflation numbers, et cetera, and maybe postpone a raise? Or is it not big enough?
+19*******34 28:03
Yeah, it could certainly. But the problem with that, right, is that we've seen that happen before. You know, that we had that memorandum of understanding that was signed back in June and crude prices dropped by 20, 25 bucks a barrel and everything felt like it was okay. This is a
Appt, Michael 28:16
Yeah.
+19*******34 28:23
the energy market, like the stock market, is a market that is extremely sensitive to headline risk, extremely sensitive to, you know, individual kind of news points and geopolitical movements. And so I don't think a central bank is going to take comfort in this idea.
that maybe there's a memorandum of understanding 2.0 that's signed tomorrow. I don't think that's enough to push people off. And by the way, Mike, if we look at the next page here, it's entitled unemployment and wages. Just kind of underscore that point about the Canadian economy. These numbers are a little bit
stale, but that unemployment rate has stuck around at 6.4% per the August numbers. That wage growth number has dropped all the way down to 2% for the August number. So again, really underscoring the kind of softness in the labour market and the fact that Canada, unlike the US maybe, but certainly Canada on its own, is not really at risk of
of heading into some sort of wage price spiral that translates into more inflationary pressure. So further, or I guess more issues for Macklem to consider as he thinks about rate policy over the coming months.
Appt, Michael 29:39
spot to be in. Speaking of that, midterms, they're coming up. How do you see that kind of playing around and playing itself out? How do we position ourselves on something like that?
+19*******34 29:41
Of.
Yeah.
Yeah, well, you know, please don't remind me. This is like my least favourite period ever a couple of years because it's where all the attention shifts for a couple of months. People get very frenzied over what ultimately from a market's perspective actually doesn't mean a whole lot. So if we look at the next
page here, it's called control of the Senate and the House are close calls. I think it's important to level set, as I'm sure probably many people dialling in would know, the midterms are for control over the American legislative branch. So this is not a presidential election that's happening in a couple of years. This is purely
for our upper house and our lower house, the Senate and the House of Representatives. And what we show on this slide is that at the moment, Republicans control both chambers of Congress, which means they have the legislative branch captive, in addition to the executive branch, in the form of the White House and the president.
But the margins of control in the legislative branch are extraordinarily narrow, right? There are 100 seats in the US Senate. Republicans control 53 of them. There are 435 seats in the US House of Representatives. Republicans control 220 of them. We are
barely talking about 51, 52% margins of control here. And the way the US legislative system works, for better or for worse, is that simple majorities are oftentimes not particularly good at getting anything done. Because to beat a presidential veto, where like a bill gets put on the president's desk, and then he says, nope, I don't want this.
sends it back, or to beat what's referred to as a filibuster, which will typically happen in the Senate, where an individual senator will stand up and deliver a 36-hour long speech to delay the vote of something and kind of wear away at the individuals in the room to beat those things.
you need a 60 person super majority in the Senate. And even with full Republican control of Congress right now, we don't have that super majority. So the scope of what the legislative branch is able to accomplish is relatively narrow. Now, we know, historically speaking, that midterms
typically do result in pretty significant swings in votes. Usually the incumbent party gives up seats, the opposing party picks up those seats. But we are not looking for a swing so significant that it would shift to some sort of super majority. In other words, it's more likely than not that the Democrats
take control over the House of Representatives. Maybe they even take control over the Senate, although that seems very unlikely given some of the redistricting that's happened. But they are not going to gain a super majority that would allow them to really interfere with the president's agenda. And so what you're left with then is on the legislative front, kind of
divided government in the sense that, you know, yes, there are areas where there is room for bipartisan cooperation, you know, stuff that the US and excuse me, rather the stuff that the Republicans and Democrats agree on, like being tough on China. But it's very difficult to imagine that the Democrats are willing to give the Republicans anything. So there will likely be
stagnation there. And it means that you're going to be spending that much more time really focusing in on the power, the authority of the executive branch. And as a reminder, like this is a president that has been remarkably effective at testing the boundaries of that power. And most of the things that we talk about when it comes to like President Trump's, you know, hallmark
kind of policy changes have done, have been accomplished, so to speak, largely in the absence of congressional oversight. Like the tariffs that you and I were chatting about earlier had nothing to do with Congress. You know, what happened in Iran had nothing to do with Congress. The big changes to the regulatory environment, nothing to do with Congress.
Appt, Michael 33:50
Mhm.
+19*******34 34:02
big changes to immigration policy, nothing to do with Congress. So ultimately, right, we're going to spend a lot of time thinking about the potential outcomes of these midterms. And, you know, from a political perspective and from a personal perspective, of course, it makes sense to care. But from a market's perspective, we're not actually assuming
a big change in anything, which is a point that I think is reinforced on the next slide here. It's called consumer confidence by political affiliation. Just showing, in addition to a few other things, how the US economy and the US stock market have performed under various
a presidential regimes. And you know, I think it is fascinating where if you start with Obama on the left hand side, the S&P 500 under Obama returned 16% per year. Under Trump 1.0, 16% per year. Under Biden, 13.5%, under Trump 2.0, 18% per year.
per year. We are talking about double digit returns regardless of red or blue. Look at GDP growth under Obama, 2.2 percent, under Trump, 1.8 percent, under Biden, 3 percent, under Trump, 2.7 percent. We are talking about strong, healthy, normal economic growth regardless of red or blue. And so, you know, at the end of the day, Mike, the point always has to be like, look,
Appt, Michael 35:04
Yeah.
+19*******34 35:24
It's important to pay attention to this stuff, and it's important to vote your conscious. But when it comes to markets and it comes to portfolios, we always try to emphasise rather this idea that you should not let politics get in the way of how you invest. That, I think, is always the ultimate takeaway from this kind of stuff.
Appt, Michael 35:42
Yeah, it's hard to do that sometimes in Canada, looking at your what's coming out of the States these days, but...
+19*******34 35:49
Oh, I understand, and I'm sorry.
Appt, Michael 35:54
Well, look, thank you very much. Thank you very much for taking the time. Very insightful. Thought it would be interesting to hear an American's take on what's going on, so I really appreciate you doing that. Thanks.
+19*******34 36:03
It was a pleasure. Thanks for having me.
Appt, Michael 36:05
You got it. Okay. Bye-bye.
Appt, Michael stopped transcription
Disclaimer:
CIBC Private Wealth consists of services provided by CIBC and certain of its subsidiaries, including CIBC Wood Gundy, a division of CIBC World Markets Inc. The CIBC logo and “CIBC Private Wealth” are trademarks of CIBC, used under license. “Wood Gundy” is a registered trademark of CIBC World Markets Inc.
This information, including any opinion, is based on various sources believed to be reliable, but its accuracy cannot be guaranteed and is subject to change. CIBC and CIBC World Markets Inc., their affiliates, directors, officers and employees may buy, sell, or hold a position in securities of a company mentioned herein, its affiliates or subsidiaries, and may also perform financial advisory services, investment banking or other services for, or have lending or other credit relationships with the same. CIBC World Markets Inc. and its representatives may receive sales commissions and/or a spread between bid and ask prices if you purchase, sell or hold the securities referred to above. © CIBC World Markets Inc. 2026
If you are currently a CIBC Wood Gundy client, please contact your Investment Advisor.
2024 Federal Budget and Beyond
Discussion with Debbie Pearl-Weinberg, Executive Director of Tax & Estate Planning with CIBC Private Wealth, on how capital gains will be taxed.
2024 Federal Budget and Beyond
May 21, 2024, 9:02PM
38m 55s
[Welcome Slide]
[CIBC Private Logo, “Capital Gains Tax Planning”]
[Guest Speaker is Debbie Pearl-Weinberg – Executive Director, Tax and Estate Planning]
Appt, Michael:
Hello. Welcome everyone.
My name is Michael Appt and thank you very much for coming today.
As many of you are aware, the federal government has proposed a new budget could have far reaching impact on many Canadians.
Today we hope to cover off some of the common questions that we're receiving from the client base.
We have all heard that the federal budget is going to change how capital gains would be taxed in the future.
What are they?
And will they happen?
Are there any other situations that could be impacted by these changes?
Many people are questioning whether or not they should sell their investments before these changes come into effect.
Is that a good plan?
Some people have investments inside of a corporation, professional corporation, etcetera.
But how does this impact the situation?
What are the changes propose that could impact people that are selling a business?
These are some of the common questions that we've been getting. To assist in answering these questions,
Debbie Pearl Weinberg, a tax expert and estate planning lawyers joining us.
She is executive director of tax estate planning with CIBC private wealth, having previously been the general tax counsel to CIBC. Debbie is an adjunct professor at the University of Toronto Law School.
She is currently vice chair of the Investment Fund Institute of Canada's Taxation Working Group.
She writes, consults on a variety of personal and small business tax issues.
Debbie is a speaker, both internally to CIBC advisors and to industry conferences, symposiums and client events.
She's been a guest on CBC Radio 1 Ontario today, been quoted a tax expert and investment executive, global advisor, and advisor.ca Debbie over to you.
Pearl-Weinberg, Debbie:
Thank you very much, Michael.
So yes, we've had a lot of questions coming in about the capital gains, changes that were proposed in the budget.
But before I go over exactly what the changes are, I just want to make it clear that the capital gains inclusion rate hasn't always been 50%.
As a matter of fact, from 1990 until mid 2000, it was actually at a 75% inclusion rate.
So we have seen instances where the inclusion rate has gone up and where it's gone down in the past.
OK, so let's look at what the changes are and what do we even mean by capital gains inclusion rate.
[Slide titled “Proposed Budget Change”]
[Slide shows the current capital gains inclusion rate versus the proposed inclusion rate (as of June 25, 2024). It breaks down how it will affect individuals and corporations]
So currently where you earn a capital gain where you realize a capital gain on the disposition of some property, only 50% of the capital gain is included in your income.
So if you earn $100 capital gain only $50.00, you're is included in your income and you pay tax on that $50.00.
So that's what we mean by the capital gains inclusion rate.
And right now it's 50%.
What was proposed in the budget that came out last night is that as of June 25th, 2024, this will change in certain circumstances.
Now for individuals, the inclusion rate will increase to 66 2/3%.
Where an individual earned capital gains over 250,000 annually.
So for the gains over $250,000 on an annual basis, and that's cumulative, they'll be taxed to that 66 2/3% inclusion rate for gains up to 250,000 annually.
That will remain at that 50% capital gains inclusion rate.
And the one thing that is different for this year in particular is that that $250,000 threshold, it's also going to apply for gains realized between June 25th, 2024 and the end of this year.
However, for corporations and trusts, they're not going to get that $250,000 threshold.
According to the budget documents for corporations and trusts, in every situation, 66 2/3% of capital gains are included in income.
So that means earning $100 capital gain, taxed on 66 2/3% of that amount.
No threshold, but the one thing that I want to be really clear about is that no draft legislation has been released to date.
So we don't have a lot of details.
We don't know if there's going to be any exceptions, and we also don't know when draft legislation and details are going to be released.
So a lot of you know what we're presenting on is on the very basics that was included in the budget documents and what people are expecting will occur.
So I know a lot of people have questions about capital loss carry forwards and carry backs.
[Slide titled “Capital Losses”]
[Slide discussed capital loss carry forward and carry back]
Essentially, what happens if you have a capital gain that you realize in a year and you also have capital losses that you realize in a year you can offset your capital gains with capital losses.
But if you have more capital losses than capital gains, you can actually carry forward those capital losses to use in another year to offset capital gains or you can carry them back if you years three years back.
And so people are really concerned.
Well, what if I had a capital loss, you know, from two years ago where it was a 50% inclusion rate and now after June 24th, I have a 66 2/3% inclusion rate on my capital gain.
So the in the budget document it indicated that, umm capital losses from previous years will be adjusted to reflect the inclusion rate of the capital gain that is offset and that itself being used to offset.
So the capital gain and capital loss inclusion rate should always match.
[2024 Maximum Personal Tax Rates]
[Table with the following categories: Region, Eligible Dividends, Capital Gains (with 50% inclusion), New Capital Gains (with 66.67% inclusion), and Other Income]
Now in terms of what this means for tax rates and what change we can see to tax rates, I have up here, maximum personal tax rates, various provinces and you can see highlighted in red is Ontario.
So capital gains with a 50% inclusion rate for an Ontario top marginal as if it's an individual, this is for individuals pay top marginal rates, they are subject to a 26.76% inclusion rate.
So that means earn $100 of capital gains, going to pay $26.76 of tax. If that same individual is now subject to the 66.67% inclusion rate, their tax rate is going to go up on that $100 capital gain to 35.69.
So they'll pay $35.69 additional tax.
So where do we think we're going to see this impacted?
Well, lots of situations.
[Situations Impacted]
[List of Situations: Vacation properties, income/rental properties, employee stock options, charitable donations ‘in-kind’, death/estate planning, becoming non-resident, trusts, holding investments in corporations, sale of a business]
I'm just going to go over a few of these situations in our call today because we won't have time to go over every single situation and but obviously investment proposals, we're going to see that.
[Situations Impacted]
[Slide focuses on Vacation Properties/Principal residence exemption and Income/Rental properties]
But beyond investment portfolios, we're going to see vacation properties possibly impacted.
Now there is something called the principal residence exemption, where you own a home that you reside in and it doesn't have to be full year.
It can be a seasonal property.
You can have the gain exempt from tax using a principal residence exemption and this is sort of decided year by year.
You designate a property as your principal residence in a particular year.
But you can only designate one property in a year as your principal residence, and this applies for family units.
Being spouses, common law partners and minor children, so that family unit can only designate one property a year.
So when you own more than one property, let's say home and a cottage, you have to figure out where you're going to designate which property to designate as your principal residence, and you only have to do this in the year that you sell the first, because that's when you file tax return and you’re to decide whether or not you're designating that property as your personal residence.
And if you designate it for all the years that you owned it, that it's completely free of tax.
So it's going to be more important now to figure out, well, where do I see the best bang for my buck to say which gain do I see being the most on an average year by year?
So when you sell the first of those properties, what should I designate. Also really remember, especially for vacation properties where you do improvements that increases what's called your cost base of the property.
So that will reduce your gain later on if you own a property jointly, you can actually split it with your joint holder.
And the other thing that people might want to start thinking about for vacation properties is if they don't sell the during their lifetime and they you hold it on your death, there's what's called a deemed disposition on death of all your capital properties.
So you're deemed up, disposed it and you realize a capital gain or capital loss at that time.
So for cottages, what is fairly common is that people purchase life insurance to cover the taxes on any capital gain that can rise on that property on their death.
If they will not have the principal residence exemption to use, so now people might have to reevaluate well, do I have sufficient life insurance if the capital gains inclusion rate is going to be higher and it's particularly tricky if somebody can no longer if they don't qualify for insurance anymore.
So this is things that people are thinking about income or rental properties where you cannot use a principal residence exemption there.
And but again, if it's jointly owned, maybe you know if you both contributed to the property, you can split the capital gain so you can both use your $250,000 threshold to have some of the gain taxed at that lower rate.
[Situations Impacted (Continued)]
[Slide discussed Employee Stock Options and Donation of publicly listed securities in-kind]
Employee stock options not going to go into a lot, but just know if you hold employee stock options you might see an increased rate of tax when you exercise certain options after June 24th of this year.
Donations of publicly listed securities.
When you make a donation of a publicly listed security or mutual funds in kind, meaning you actually donate that property to a charity, any capital gain that you realize on the donation when you dispose of it to the charity is actually not subject to tax no tax on that gain.
So it's always generally better to if you're going to make a donation rather than selling a property publicly listed securities and then donating the proceeds, it’s better to donate the property in kind and many, many charities accept this and this will be even a better higher benefit, if that gain is subject to the 2/3 inclusion rate.
Now I talked about on death that there's a deemed disposition of all your capital property,
[Situations Impacted (Continued)]
[Slide focused on Death and Becoming a Non-resident (departure tax)]
in non-registered accounts and so even if somebody during their lifetime is under that $250,000 capital gain threshold, so their capital gains are still taxed at a 50% inclusion rate, on death they could see something different because then if all their properties need to be disposed of, it could have a higher inclusion rate for the gains over 250,000.
Now this happens on the death, if you have spouses or common law partners, this happens on the death of the second to die because there is a rollover available when property is transferred to your spouse or common law partner on death. And then just in case you have any clients who are thinking of leaving Canada becoming a non resident, we have in Canada what's called departure tax.
So again, you're deemed to dispose of most of your capital property.
Canadian real estate is an exception.
But your other capital property, you're deemed to have disposed of when you leave Canada and you could realize capital gains and have to pay tax at that time.
And again, that could be over 250,000 even if, while you were resident in Canada, you really didn't have that high capital gains.
[Trusts]
[Slide contains information on: More Trusts (personal and mutual funds), Alter-ego and joint spousal/common-law partner trust, and Estates]
Trusts.
Now I know Michael had some clients asking about either personal trust, prescribing loans to personal trust, or they've invested in mutual funds, ETF's, hedge funds, mutual funds, hedge funds, ETFs are all types of trust.
Some of them are corporations, but most of them are trusts.
So remember, for trusts they don't have this $250,000 threshold of gains taxed at that lower 50% inclusion rate.
However, it's not an issue for most trusts because distribute all their income and gains out to beneficiaries each year.
So then it'll be taxed in the beneficiaries hands and the beneficiaries, the individuals should be eligible for that $250,000 threshold again.
We are not sure.
There's no details yet.
I can tell you that the mutual fund industry is really, you know, looking into this and asking questions of the government is anticipated that for 2024 that whether or not something is included at the 50% inclusion rate or the higher inclusion rate will be dependent on when the trust realizes the capital gain and not when it's distributed to beneficiary.
But we really have to wait for the draft legislation to be able to confirm that.
The one exception where this could be an issue is for something called alter ego, spousal trusts, joint spousal trusts, common law partner trust.
These are all type of trusts where one person is entitled to all of the income from the trust while they're alive and possibly capital from the trust as well.
But nobody else can get anything income capital from the trust and on their deaths, or if it's a joint trust, joint partner or joint spousal trust on the death of the second of those people to die, the residual amount in the trust goes to the residual beneficiary.
So for instance.
Michael can set up what's called an alter ego trust for himself and then on his death, his children could be the beneficiaries.
Or he could set one up for him and his spouse.
Or sometimes you see people set up these trusts in their wills for their spouse to get all their property in a spousal trust.
And whatever is left after their spouse passes away goes to their children, and this is very common actually in the case of second marriages, where you want to support your spouse from the second marriage, but you want the residual amount to go to your children from your first marriage.
Now on the death of the individual who's entitled to the income and capital during their lifetime, before the property goes to those residual beneficiaries, say the children, there is a deemed disposition in the trust.
All the property in the trust and the trust actually has to pay the tax on those capital gains.
And if the rules don't make an exclusion for these type of trust, then all those capital gains that are earned in the trust on the death of this income beneficiary during their lifetime, those will be taxed at that higher marginal tax rate.
So we'll have to see whether or not there's an exclusion for those types of trusts.
And people also asked, well, what about estates?
Because estates are, they're actually a trust.
So after somebody passes away, whatever property doesn't go yet to your beneficiary, it's held in the estate, which is a type of trust.
Some estates have a better tax treatment.
They're called graduated rate estates, so usually for the first three years after your gap, your estate is called what's called a graduated rate estates.
So it gets graduated rate tax treatment just like we do as individuals.
The same type of thing the tax rate goes up.
The more income that is earned in the in the trust. Most trusts are subject to just tax at the highest marginal tax rate.
But either way, whether it's a graduated various state or a non-graduated rate estate, either way, that estate, unless there's an exclusion made in the draft legislation, will be subject to tax at that 66 2/3% inclusion rate on capital gains that are earned within the estate.
And no $250,000 threshold.
[The Big Question]
[Slides contains the following questions: Do we trigger capital gains before June 25, 2024? Do we trigger capital gains of $250,000 annually?]
[Slide provides CRA technical information, on when the General Anti-Avoidance rules does not apply]
So I'm sure you been getting questions about this Michael, and big question, do we trigger capital gains before June 25th, 2024 or after that date?
Should we start triggering $250,000 of capital gains annually?
So to make sure that in subsequent years in a way we have gains taxed at that 50% inclusion rate rather than the higher inclusion rate.
So the first question in the tax community well, will the Canada revenue agency , CRA apply guard, which is something called the general Anti avoidance rule to change the tax consequences.
If you do this, if you purposely trigger gains to get this lower inclusion rate and the Canada Revenue Agency actually issued a technical interpretation earlier a couple weeks ago and indicated that they're not.
If people purposely trigger capital gains before June 25th, they're not going to apply the general anti avoidance rule in those situations, unless something else is going on.
[ON 2024 Example: Planning for an increase in the CG inclusion rate]
[Slides contains information on the following: What is the cost with the new CG Inclusion Rate]
[Slide breaks down Strategy 1: Individual trigger accrued CG before June 25, 2024]
[Slide breaks down Strategy 2: Individual trigger annual CG of $250,000]
[Slides introduces topic of Time value of tax repayment]
So let's look at what the what the actual cost is with this new increase in the capital gains inclusion rate and what people need to think about before they trigger gains prior to June 25th of this year.
So, for this is for individuals, so the top personal tax rate right now on capital gains is 26.76%.
So that's with the 50% inclusion rate and somebody tax at the highest marginal tax rate in Ontario.
And that will go up to 35.69% for capital gains subject to tax at that higher inclusion rate.
So we're seeing an increase of 8.93% for capital gains subject to the new inclusion rate.
So, strategy number one, people are thinking about well, should I just trigger capital gains before June 25th?
So for every $100,000 of capital gains, there will be a tax savings of 8930 compared to capital gains that are above 250,000 after that date.
Or do you trigger annual capital gains of $250,000 on a $250,000 capital gain?
You're looking at a savings of $22,325 each year.
When $250,000 of capital gains are taxed at that lower inclusion rate rather than the higher inclusion rate.
So, there's the time value of prepayment.
[Time Value of tax prepayment – an example]
[Slide contains example of Ontario 2024 – Should an individual trigger annual CG of $250,000?]
[The slide breaks down the difference or additional tax, between the current tax rate and the new tax rate. It asks the Time Value Question: do you pre-pay a certain amount earlier to save in taxes overall?]
So that's look at that.
Let's look at that and we'll look at the second question.
Should an individual trigger an annual capital gain of 250,000. So again, tax rate on your first 250,000 annually will be at that 26.76% on $250,000 of capital gains you’re looking at tax of $66,900.
If you earn it after June 25th, 2024 and it's over that original $250,000 threshold, you're looking at tax at a rate of 35.69.
So overall, tax on that $250,000 gain will be $89,225.00.
So that is a difference of $22,325.00 that's the additional tax that you pay.
So here's the question, do I prepay $66,900 of tax earlier than you would have to save $22,325 in taxes overall?
And the question is, what is the time value of that money?
Because you're pre-paying, right?
So what you have to look at is the time frame that you'll be holding that answer, how long until you're planning on selling and what is your rate of return on it?
And so there's been calculations done on various rates of return and how long it's going take to break even and at a 6% rate of return, this is just capital gains, deferred capital gains calculations have indicated it's been take about 8 years to break even.
So those are the thought processes that people are going to have to go through and deciding whether or not you're going to sell now or you're going to hold because in the long term you'll be better off holding and not prepaying tax and having that amount to be invested.
[Situations Impacted (Continued)]
[Slide breaks down Holding Investments in a Corporation]
So what I've just gone through all those analysis and all those tax rates were for individuals.
So somebody holding assets personally, rather than holding them in a corporation and when you hold property in a corporation the tax is different.
There's two levels of tax.
First of all, corporation pays tax when it earns income and then when amounts are distributed to you as a shareholder, you pay tax at the shareholder level.
So what you have to look at is the overall tax rate of burning it inside a corporation.
And what will the change be there?
So you know, the first issue is that there is no $250,000 threshold where the first, you know amount of taxable gains will still be subject to that 50% inclusion rate at the budget has said that all capital gains are into incorporation after June 24th of this year will be subject to the higher inclusion rate.
So this is going to impact, you know, all sorts of corporations and it will impact professional corporations because often professional and corporations, the reason for incorporating was that if you don't need all the income that you're earning professionally, if you earn it inside a corporation and you don't take it all out because active business income is taxed at a lower rate initially inside the corporation, then if you earned it personally, you can save more in the corporation if you leave it in there and don't take it out because you have more to invest inside the corporation, until you take it out.
So there's going to be an impact to professional corporations because tax will now be at higher rate.
There's also another reason that some people hold investments in the corporation, and there can be many other reasons, but one common reason that we see is where people are concerned about US estate tax.
So even as a Canadian, non US person never lived in the states, are not a U.S. citizen or non US person, if you hold a high amount of large amount of US situs properties.
So it could be stocks and bonds of US issuer as it could be US real estate and you're above a certain exemption amount when you pass away U.S estate tax could be owing and one way that people.
A minimize or eliminate this US state tax is that they hold investments in a corporation because corporation is not subject to the US estate tax, and so the individual isn't holding the assets directly.
Now, there's always been a cost of earning US dividends in a corporation and now there's going to be this added cost of the capital gain being earned inside a corporation. So people are going have to think about that when they're considering whether or not they're going use U.S estate tax.
So I indicated that when you're looking at taxes, when you're looking at capital gains earned from corporation, you have to look at both what is paid in the corporation and what's paid when is taken out.
And so that combined corporate and personal tax rates.
[ON 2024 Integration Summary]
[Slide contains a table with the following columns: income type, corporate tax rate, integrated corporate/personal tax rates, personal highest tax rate, tax savings (cost)]
So in the corporation, when it's earned, when it's taken out, what an individual pays as taxes on the dividend income it receives when it takes out that after tax amount of the capital gain that's called the integrated tax rate.
So when we look at a corporation in Ontario and an individual again earning the top marginal tax rate in Ontario, when you look at what the corporation will pay and then what the individual pays when they take it out, that overall combined tax rate on a capital gain in Ontario is 28.96%.
Now compare it to the tax that an individual would or looking if they aren't a direct directly
That would be 26.76%.
So what we say there is there's a 2.2% tax cost in earning it through a corporation.
And again, there's reasons of earning it through a corporation.
As we just said, for professional corporations you people have and earning them through a corporation and then had more to save and so earned higher amounts of investment income and their portfolio grows at a larger rate.
So that 2.2% tax clause and capital gains, not horrible if we look at the going up and inclusion rate.
So this now this 66.67% inclusion rate, the overall integrated cost of earning that capital gain in a corporation and then hang it out to an individual, it's 38.62%.
And again at the individual had to pay tax at that higher inclusion rate, they would pay 35.69%.
So that's only a bit higher of a tax cost 2.9% versus 2.2%.
So that's not, that's not horrible only, you know, point 7% increase in the overall tax cost.
But I think what people also need to look at is, well, what if I, as an individual, if I earn the capital gain directly?
I only pay tax at the 50% inclusion rate, whereas if Corporation earned that capital gain, it would pay tax at that higher inclusion rate.
So how do you compare that?
Well, let's look at that.
[Cost of Earning $250,000 capital gains in corp vs personal (from June 25,2024)
[Slide contains table with the following columns: Region, Integrated Tax rate as of June 25,2024, Top personal tax rate as of June 25,2024, and Tax Savings (Cost)]
And on this slide, sorry, I don't have it highlighted, but if you look down to Ontario, you're going to see that.
So you're integrated tax rate in Ontario as of June 25th, 2024 is 38.62%, so that means you're earning your capital gain in the corporation pay tax in the corporation takes out of the corporation.
It's the dividend that's the combined rate corporation and you pay on that same capital gain.
So $100 capital gain $38.62 of tax will be paid overall, whereas as an individual, if I have less than $250,000 of capital gains in a year, I'm only going pay tax at 26.76%.
So I'm going to only pay $26.76.
So now we're looking at an 11.86% tax cost so that is a much higher tax cost, so you have to think about, you know, wearing earning capital gains compared to earning individual that individually and what tax rate would the individual even pay on it.
So you can see that it's an even more complicated question.
When you're earning those capital gains through a corporation and sorry to make it even muddier, but that's just what we're left with.
So next let's move a little bit of away from the capital gains inclusion rate.
Let's look at sale of the business and other things that have come out of the budget.
[2024 lifetime capital gains exemption (LCGE)]
[Slides discusses lifetime capital gains exemption when selling shares of a corporation]
So the first thing is when you sell a certain items such as shares of a corporation that was carrying on a business you might be eligible for something called the lifetime capital gains exemption, and this applies when you sell first of all, farming or fishing property.
Don't know if anybody holds that on this call, but also where you have something called qualified Small Business Corporation shares and I'll go through the requirements in a minute, but the amount of this exemption.
So when this exemption applies, capital gain up to this amount is exempt from tax, no tax on it.
And it's a lifetime amount.
You can use this one over your lifetime.
This total amount over your lifetime.
So right now the lifetime capital gains exemption is 1.016 million just over that, and it's indexed annually, but the Budget indicated is that is going to go up now to 1.25 million for capital gains realized on or after June 25th, 2024, and then starting in 2026 it will be indexed again.
So how do you get this?
What are the requirements to qualify for this?
So first of all, at the time of sale, the time that you sell the shares over 90, at least 90% of the assets and the corporation have to be used in active business.
And so that means you might have to get rid of some investments in the corporation if you want to do that sale, and also in the two years in the 24 months prior to the sale, at least 50% of the assets have to be used in active business.
So that's planning that people do prior to sale and they try and do that a few years prior to thinking about a sale.
[Canadian Entrepreneurs’ Incentive (CEI)]
[The slide breaks down how this incentive will be helpful to people operating a business through a corporation]
So that's good if you qualify for that Something else that the Budget introduced that can be helpful to some people operating a business through a corporation is a new incentive called the Canadian Entrepreneurs Incentive.
And where this applies and you sell a business then the capital gains inclusion rate will be 1/2 of what it would have been otherwise.
So, for instance, if you're capital gains inclusion rate would have been 66.67%, it will be 33.33%.
[Canadian Entrepreneurs’ Incentive (CEI) phase-in)
[Slide contains table with the following columns: Year and CEI]
This is going to start next year, January for sales as of January 1, 2025, but it's going to come in over time.
So it'll be effective as of 2034 for gains up to $2,000,000.
So it will be quite useful as it rolls in.
[Canadian Entrepreneurs’ Incentive (CEI): Conditions]
[Slide discusses conditions for CEI at: time of sale, during 24 months prior to sale, and the individual claiming the CEI]
And when can you use this?
So very similar conditions as for the lifetime capital gains exemption at the time of sale, you have 90% of your assets used in active business and 24 months prior to the sale at least 50% of the assets have to be used in an active business. But then the for the individual claiming this Canadian entrepreneurs incentive, it's a little different and they have to be a founding investor and hold shares for at least five years owned 10% of votes of value and have to be actively involved for at least five years prior to the sale.
[Canadian Entrepreneurs’ Incentive (CEI): Exclusions]
[Slide provides list where CEI won’t apply to shares of professional corporations and corporations whose principal business is: financial, insurance, real estate, food and accommodation, arts, recreation, entertainment, consulting and personal care service]
But the big issue with this is that there's a lot of exceptions that it doesn't apply to and one of the big ones is professional corporations.
So professional corporations will not be eligible for this incentive, and you can see there's a lot of other types of businesses that will be not, but won't be as well.
But let's assume you have a manufacturing business and you can utilize, this exemption.
[Example of tax on capital gains when Canadian Entrepreneur’s Incentive (CEI)]
[Slide demonstrates what to account for, during the sale of a business: LCGE, CEI, 50% inclusion rate, 66.67% inclusion rate]
I'm just going go through illustrating all the different incentives that you could use if you sell something in 2034. So the first is that the 1st 1.25 million, well, that will be an indexed amount, so some amount higher than that of the capital gain will be completely exempt from tax if the lifetime capital gains exemption is available. On the next $2,000,000 of proceeds or sorry of gain, assuming that you qualify for this Canadian entrepreneurs incentive that will be taxable at a 33.33% tax rate as sorry inclusion rate not tax, rate inclusion rate.
And then on the next $250,000 capital gain, you'll get 50% inclusion rate and anything over to that will be subject to this fire 66.67% inclusion.
[Should I sell or Should I hold? Capital Gains Tax Planning]
[Slide discusses a report from Debbie’s team, that is now available on cibc.com]
And before I end I just wanted to tell you about one recent report that our group has put out.
It's should I sell or should I hold capital gains tax, mining and it's up on cibc.com but if you would like the link sent to you, Michael, I'm sure you could assist with that.
Appt, Michael:
Definitely
Pearl-Weinberg, Debbie:
And with that, I don't know if there's been any questions.
Appt, Michael:
Great.
Yeah, we there's a function on the top here of the webinar we can ask questions, it says Q&A.
So if anybody has any questions, you can hit that button up there and put it into the chat, but actually got a question right now a little bit unrelated, but he writes.
If I saw my whole principal residence in Toronto, can I designate a vacation home in Florida as my principal residence for tax purposes?
Pearl-Weinberg, Debbie:
So I think what the person's asking for future.
So I've already sold my Canadian home.
So now I only own one home.
Can I start designating that Florida home?
Yes you can, but that's for Canadian tax purposes.
Appt, Michael:
That's how I read it, yeah.
Pearl-Weinberg, Debbie:
Again, there's going to be U.S.
Tax on that sales right.
Appt, Michael:
Right. OK.
No, I don't see any of the others come through.
So I want take this time to thank you, Debbie.
It's certainly a complicated topic and very far reaching, so thanks for taking the time to do this.
As always, if everybody has any questions about their personal situation, you can send me an email directly.
Pearl-Weinberg, Debbie:
No problem.
Appt, Michael:
We can assist with that because situations are different for everybody.
We will send out a recording of this after the fact, along with copy of the presentation at Debbie referred to.
So thanks everybody again for taking the time and enjoy your evening.
OK, bye.
Pearl-Weinberg, Debbie:
Bye. Bye.
Thanks Michael.