What rising rates and inflation mean for Canada’s economy
“Not all rate hike cycles certainly end in recession” says CIBC’s Avery Shenfeld. He adds that some companies should tolerate higher interest rates.
WHAT RISING RATES AND INFLATION MEAN FOR CANADA’S ECONOMY
It seems like as soon as central banks start raising interest rates and we're seeing that
in both the U.S. and Canada, you get those stories about the R word that is recession.
[The exteriors of the Federal Reserve and the Bank of Canada.]
People start to worry that a rate hike cycle inevitably has its conclusion, not just in
easing inflation, but sending the economy spinning downward.
[The Federal Reserve in Washington. The European Central Bank in Frankfurt.]
And while that has sometimes been true in past tightening cycles, there have been a
number of cycles where the central banks hiked rates for a while, then paused or even
eased rates a bit, and the cycle continued. And I would argue that if you look back to
where we were in 2019, we were exactly at that point.
[The exteriors of the Federal Reserve and the Bank of Canada.]
The Bank of Canada had stopped raising rates at relatively low rates of interest and the
economy was still moving forward. And the U.S. had actually started to ease off a little
bit on interest rates in 2019 and might have averted a recession if not for the
emergence of COVID-19.
[A man wears a mask and looks out the window. Busy hospital hallways.]
So not all rate hike cycles certainly end in recession, and there are some reasons to
expect that Canada and many Canadian-listed companies should be able to tolerate
higher rates of interest than we've now seen in the past.
[Can Canadians tolerate higher rates?]
Even if you look at Canada's household sector, albeit a very indebted household sector,
it's not like the first couple of years of rate hikes are going to be all that much of a
squeeze on that sector of the Canadian economy.
[Aerial views of suburban neighbourhoods in Canada.]
Remember that the mortgages, for example, that will come due in 2022 and 2023.
These were mortgages that typically, if they were four- or five-year mortgages, were
taken out before the pandemic at interest rates that are probably quite close to where
mortgage rates will be over 2022 and 2023.
[Images of people signing mortgage documents. A man is handed a folder and a set of
keys.]
So, they'll be higher than they were at the height of the pandemic. But those mortgages
won't come due until 2024 or 2025. The Bank of Canada also understands the debt
level of Canadians and should be careful to perhaps pause on the way towards higher
interest rates to make sure that the economy is living with that. Ultimately, we do see
short-term interest rates getting into the sort of mid 2% range in both the U.S. and
Canada.
[Images of people wearing masks in a city. Vials of COVID-19 vaccines.]
That should be something the economy can live with over the medium term if COVID
manages to behave itself and not return to a full force anytime soon.
[Outlook for investors]
The question is for investors, how much of a dent does this do? It certainly has raised
concerns about companies that have all their earnings way off in the future because
you're now discounting that flow of earnings at a higher interest rate. So the growth
companies that don't have a lot of current profitability certainly have been marked down
by the equity market. It does pose a bit of a challenge for companies whose only value
is as a substitute for bonds.
But then there's a whole group of companies that will benefit from the ongoing growth in
the Canadian economy. It is, after all, that growth that is compelling central banks to
start raising interest rates. And therefore, there certainly should be elements of the
equity market that benefit more from the further improvement in economic activity than
they're hurt by the rise in interest rates.
[Inflation]
We are, of course, monitoring the spike in inflation. The longer it persists, the more
there will be a concern that central banks really have to dole out severe punishment to
the economy to get that back down.
[A shipping barge docked in ice. An empty warehouse. An empty supermarket. The
Ukrainian flag.]
But we do believe that some of the inflation we're seeing today is still the remnants of
supply chain difficulties caused by COVID, as well as, more recently, the war in Ukraine.
And as we look ahead to 2023, at least those elements of inflation should give way to
much lower rates of inflation on things like energy prices and other things impacted by
the war. And we're hoping that therefore it only takes a modest cooling in economic
growth in Canada, in the U.S., and therefore a relatively moderately paced dose of rate
hikes to get overall inflation back under control. We'll be keeping an eye on that
forecast, of course. But as I said at the outset, no hard and fast rule that central banks
have to err on the side of causing a recession. And certainly, a number of cases in the
past where they've successfully managed to pool growth without taking the whole
economy down with it.
[This video is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute
financial, investment, tax, legal or accounting advice nor does it constitute an offer or
solicitation to buy or sell any securities referred to. Individual circumstances and current
events are critical to sound investment planning; anyone wishing to act on this
document should consult with his or her advisor. All opinions and estimates expressed
in this video are as of the date of publication unless otherwise indicated, and are subject
to change.
The CIBC logo is a trademark of Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC).
The material and/or its contents may not be reproduced without the express written
consent of CIBC.]
[CIBC Logo]
[This logo is a trademark of CIBC, used under license.]